Coronavirus: Self-isolation payment for low-income workers

The benefit will be trialled in some parts of north-west England where coronavirus cases have risen.

Share Button

Health24.com | Antibiotics might lower effectiveness of birth control pill

  • There is some evidence that antibacterial drugs interact with hormonal contraceptives
  • This means that women on the Pill should be careful when taking antibiotics
  • Researchers recommend that pharmacy inserts of both kinds of drugs should warn patients of the risk

Doctors have long suspected it, but a comprehensive new study provides more evidence that antibiotics can reduce the effectiveness of birth control pills.

That means women who are using both types of drugs at once should take extra precautions to avoid an unintended pregnancy, the study’s British authors say.

The study couldn’t prove cause and effect. However, it “suggests there is an interaction of antibacterial drugs with hormonal contraceptives, which can potentially impair the effectiveness of the contraceptives,” concluded a team led by Dr Robin Ferner of the Institute of Clinical Sciences at the University of Birmingham.

Additional contraception

The findings didn’t surprise one American ob-gyn.

“We have known for a long time that certain antibiotics will affect the metabolism of the oral contraceptive hormones,” said Dr Mitchell Kramer, who directs obstetrics and gynaecology at Northwell Health’s Huntington Hospital in Huntington, New York.

“Therefore, we advise of patients on birth control pills to use additional contraception, such as condoms or spermicidal suppositories/foam, during the duration of taking the antibiotic just as a precaution,” he said.

According to the UK research team, prior studies on interactions between antibiotics and birth control pills had yielded mixed findings.

Seeking clarity, Ferner and his team tracked reports of suspected unwanted drug side effects (called Yellow Cards) that had been reported by health care providers and the public to the UK’s drug and medical devices regulator, the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency.

Unintended pregnancies

Specifically, they compared the number of unintended pregnancies reported in almost 75 000 Yellow Cards for antibiotics in general, about 33 000 for enzyme-inducing drugs, and more than 65 500 other types of drugs.

There were 46 instances of unintended pregnancies in the Yellow Card reports for antibiotics (a rate of 62 per 100 000), 39 in the enzyme-inducing drug reports (119 per 100 000), and six in reports of other drugs.

Compared with the other types of drugs, unintended pregnancies were seven times more common in Yellow Card reports of antibiotics and 13 times more common in reports of enzyme-inducing drugs, which included some antibiotics.

Congenital birth defects were also reported seven times more often in enzyme-inducing drug Yellow Card reports, according to the study, published on 18 August in the journal BMJ Evidence Based Medicine.

Calculating absolute risks from the data wasn’t possible, and the risk will vary from woman to woman, according to her physiological make-up and circumstances, the researchers stressed.

Warnings needed

They agreed that if a woman is taking hormonal contraceptives and an antibiotic, she is “advised to take extra contraceptive precautions when a short course of an antibacterial drugs is added”.

Dr Jennifer Wu is an ob-gyn at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City. Reading over the study, she said it was well-designed, with “large numbers and good tracking of patients”.

Based on the findings, Wu believes that “doctors and patients need to have careful discussions about new prescriptions and whether they could interfere with birth control pills.

“Pharmacy inserts of antibiotics and the enzyme-inducing drugs should also warn patients as another precaution,” she said.

Image credit: Shutterstock

NEXT ON HEALTH24X

Share Button

Period poverty: Schools ‘not aware’ they can order free tampons

Charities say the scheme should be promoted after less than 40% of schools order free products.

Share Button

Health24.com | Is a ‘twindemic’ of Covid-19 and flu coming this autumn?

  • With autumn on the doorstep in the US, there is the possibility of two overlapping epidemics
  • A bad outbreak of ‘regular’ flu combined with an upsurge in Covid-19 could overwhelm health services
  • Getting the latest flu shot can reduce one’s risk of at least one of the respiratory infections

Autumn is approaching, and so is the possibility of what public health officials are calling a “twindemic” – overlapping epidemics of both Covid-19 and influenza.

A bad flu season coupled with continued Covid-19 outbreaks could increase people’s risk of fatal illness and overwhelm hospital capacity in communities already scrambling to treat coronavirus patients, experts say.

“I think it’s definitely a possibility and it’s something we’re all worried about,” said Dr Eric Cioe-Pena, director of global health at Northwell Health in New Hyde Park, New York. “The trifecta of a bad flu season, a bad Covid resurgence and an Atlantic hurricane is our doomsday scenario. You could add in civil unrest around the election as a four-way doomsday scenario.”

Blunting the effect of one infection

The concern is so great that officials worldwide have been pressing for people to get this year’s flu shot, even though it’s only now hitting the market.

Getting your flu shot “could at least blunt the effect of one of those two potential respiratory infections”, Dr Anthony Fauci, director of the US National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, told The New York Times.

Fauci shared his thoughts on vaccination in this video:

The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention usually purchases a half-million doses of flu vaccine for uninsured adults, but this year the agency increased its order by an additional 9.3 million doses, according to the Times.

But the protective strategies that officials have been promoting against Covid-19 – masking, hand-washing and physical distancing – should reduce the risk of a twindemic.

“The same things we do to prevent Covid should work for another virus called influenza,” said Dr Waleed Javaid, director of infection prevention and control at Mount Sinai Downtown, in New York City. “If we follow the same recommendations, they should be effective for influenza and for Covid, and we might not see as much spread of influenza as we’ve seen in previous years.”

Indeed, the Southern Hemisphere is in the middle of its flu season and has seen a dramatic decrease in flu cases thanks to protective measures adopted against the new coronavirus.

The Australian experience

“In Australia, the flu cases are down around 99% compared with last year,” noted Dr Amesh Adalja, a senior scholar with the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security, in Baltimore.

Unfortunately, the United States probably won’t see this benefit because the nation has not fully embraced the recommended protections against Covid-19, Adalja continued.

“There is likely to be some effect, but the fact of the matter is even though we have all these measures for Covid, in the United States we haven’t really been as adherent to them as in other countries. We have to prepare for the fact that we may not get the Australian experience of influenza,” Adalja said.

A community facing a twindemic could soon find itself running out of hospital capacity, Adalja added.

‘Back to back’ cases

Last year’s flu season was relatively mild, but still resulted in between 39 million and 56 million cases of flu, as many as 740 000 hospitalisations, and between 24 000 and 62 000 flu deaths, according to preliminary CDC estimates.

“You have to remember those viruses are going to compete for the same hospital beds, ICU beds, ventilators, personal protective equipment and even diagnostic test reagents,” Adalja said.

Doctors are particularly worried about people who catch one of the viruses and then the other, back-to-back.

“I would say a sequential infection could be really a major problem for somebody, to get hit twice in a row. They might have sustained lung damage from Covid and now have to deal with influenza,” Adalja said. “I would think the lung damage one would induce would make you more susceptible to a severe outcome with the other one.”

Both infections at once

That’s why public health officials are pressing for as many people as possible to get the flu shot, so they have some protection against at least one of these circulating viruses.

Cioe-Pena said, “We can’t vaccine-prevent Covid, but we can vaccine-prevent flu visits to hospitals this year. I strongly encourage everyone to get their flu shot.”

The flu vaccine contains particles of three to four different strains of flu that officials guess will be the ones most in circulation during the influenza season in any given year. Even if the vaccine is not an exact match to the flu that winds up being most common, it primes the body to produce an immune response that will limit the severity of a person’s illness.

“People say I took it one year and I got the flu anyway,” Cioe-Pena said. “What you will notice is there are very few people who say, ‘My loved one or I got the flu shot and then I was on a ventilator with pneumonia.’ Even when it doesn’t prevent the illness, it is still the best tool we have at attenuating the effects of the flu.”

In the most severe recent flu season, 2017-2018, the flu vaccine only had an overall estimated effectiveness of 38% across three strains, and was particularly weak against the H3N2 strain, the CDC reported.

Nonetheless, the CDC estimated that the imperfect vaccine still prevented 7.1 million illnesses, 3.7 million medical visits, 109 000 hospitalisations and 8 000 deaths that season.

Record number of shots

“It does prevent severe flu,” Javaid said, “and that is going to be the critical element in this situation. I have seen people get flu and Covid back-to-back, and I can tell you that people who were vaccinated had much better outcomes.”

During the six influenza seasons from 2010 through 2016, the flu vaccine prevented as many as 6.7 million cases of flu, 3.1 million doctor’s visits, 87 000 hospitalisations and 10 000 deaths, the CDC said in its report on this year’s flu vaccine.

Vaccine producers are preparing for a record 98 million flu shots to be handed out in the United States, about 15% more than last year, the Times reported.

However, Americans remain vaccine-hesitant. In the 2018–2019 flu season, only 45% of US adults got the vaccine, with rates particularly low among those aged 18 to 50, the Times noted.

“The best way to prevent this twindemic is to have as high a vaccination rate for influenza as we can, so there is room to take care of these Covid patients and we don’t have to worry about dual infections or sequential infections,” Adalja concluded.

Image credit: iStock

Share Button

UK flu jab rates prompt complacency warning

Experts fear the winter flu season could coincide with a rise in Covid-19 infections.

Share Button

Health24.com | Mediterranean diet might lower your odds for Parkinson’s

  • Parkinson’s disease affects nearly one million people in the United States 
  • Certain symptoms can arise years before the more obvious movement problems 
  • There are reasons to suspect that diet is involved in the development of Parkinson’s disease

People who eat healthfully may be less likely to develop a constellation of symptoms that can precede Parkinson’s disease, a large new study suggests.

Researchers found that people who closely adhered to a Mediterranean-style diet were about one-third less likely to develop at least three “prodromal” features suggestive of Parkinson’s disease, compared to those who stuck with meat and potatoes.

Prodromal refers to certain symptoms that can arise years before the more obvious movement problems that mark Parkinson’s. They include constipation, depression, body pain, diminished sense of smell, daytime drowsiness, difficulty seeing colours and a tendency to “act out” dreams.

Multiple symptoms

Individually, some of those issues are quite common, said James Beck, chief scientific officer for the nonprofit Parkinson’s Foundation. And it’s unclear, he added, how often combinations of those symptoms foretell Parkinson’s, specifically.

That said, multiple symptoms do suggest “something’s going wrong in the central nervous system”, said Beck, who was not involved in the study.

And if diet does influence the risk, he said, it will be important to figure out why.

The study, published online in Neurology, is not the first to link diet to Parkinson’s. Several have found a relationship between diet patterns – or particular foods or nutrients – and the risk of developing full-blown Parkinson’s disease.

The new findings are consistent with that, said lead researcher Samantha Molsberry, a postdoctoral research fellow at Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health in Boston.

Her team focused on prodromal symptoms, she said, because there has been a “big push” to better understand that phase of Parkinson’s. One hope is to be able to diagnose the disease earlier in its course.

Wide-ranging effects

Parkinson’s disease affects nearly one million people in the United States alone, according to the Parkinson’s Foundation.

It involves an abnormal buildup of a protein called alpha-synuclein in the brain. Over time, the brain loses cells that produce dopamine, a chemical that helps regulate movement and emotional responses. The most visible symptoms of Parkinson’s are movement-related – tremours, stiff limbs and coordination problems – but the effects are wide-ranging and include depression, irritability, and trouble with memory and thinking skills.

But years before the “classic” symptoms of Parkinson’s set in, people can develop prodromal signs.

It’s not clear what sets off the whole process. But experts think the disease arises from a mix of genetic vulnerability and nongenetic factors, according to the Parkinson’s Foundation. Older age is a risk factor, and studies have pointed to some environmental factors – including job exposures to pesticides or heavy metals.

The new findings do not prove diet directly affects the risk, Molsberry said.

But, she added, there are reasons to suspect diet is involved. In theory, a healthy diet could be protective by lowering inflammation throughout the body. And, Molsberry said, early evidence suggests alpha-synuclein may actually first “misfold” and accumulate in the gut.

It’s possible, she speculated, that diet could influence that process.

Multiple prodromal symptoms

For this study, the Harvard team analysed data from two long-running studies of thousands of US healthcare professionals. The researchers used participants’ responses to questionnaires to calculate diet “scores” for each.

One score gauged their adherence to a Mediterranean-style diet – high in fruits, vegetables, legumes, fish, whole grains and unsaturated fats from sources like olive oil.

Overall, people who scored in the top 20% were one-third less likely to develop multiple prodromal symptoms over 20 years, compared to people in the bottom 20%.

The findings were similar when researchers used another diet score, called the Alternate Healthy Eating Index. Again, people on the high-scoring end ate plenty of fruits, vegetables and whole grains, but went light on red meat, sugar and saturated fat.

Replacing junk foods

Beck said more research is needed to understand why diet is linked to prodromal features. “Is it because people on a healthy diet have less exposure to pesticides or heavy metals?” he said. “Is there an effect on inflammation?”

In the meantime, there is no downside to replacing junk food with fruits and vegetables, Beck suggested.

Molsberry agreed. “I think this is one more reason to encourage people to eat a healthy diet,” she said.

Image credit: iStock

Share Button

Covid-19: Five ways to avoid catching the virus indoors

Good ventilation could be key to avoiding coronavirus this autumn as people spend more time indoors.

Share Button

A Solution to Admin Baiting

One issue that would sometimes arise in our old public discussion forums could be described as admin baiting.

This is when some members assert the right to ask an administrative question, challenge a community rule or its application, or challenge an admin decision – by posting a message in the forum community for all to see.

From the perspective of an individual member, this makes some degree of sense. That person is a member of the community and asserts the right to pose such questions or challenges, expecting a staff member to answer them. From their perspective it may seem similar to sending an email or private message to a staff member. They could also justify posting the message publicly by considering that maybe other members would like to chime in as well, or perhaps others might be interested in the answers. So yeah, on that level I agree that it may seem like a reasonable thing to do.

This practice gets very problematic when you consider the admin perspective though. From the admin’s viewpoint, it’s much easier to see why this sort of behavior could be seen as an unreasonable form of entitlement.

Interestingly, I virtually never see this kind of behavior in certain groups that I’ve participated in, including groups consisting of entrepreneurs, coaches, or website owners. When I think about the culture of those groups, I’d say that most members would likely consider it rude or obnoxious to do this. Those community cultures wouldn’t reward this kind of behavior and would frown on it if a member did this, especially if it happened semi-regularly. They’d expect admin-related matters to be handled privately. When admin matters are handled within the public space of the group, there can be a real risk of stirring up drama and distraction for the community.

In other communities, this type of behavior can be very common, including in communities I’ve managed. A lot of communities have it; it’s usually just a question of how much. If you’ve ever managed your own community, how often have you seen members practice admin baiting? Did you feel obligated to answer publicly?

In our public forums, I didn’t see this as too big of a deal. We had a dozen volunteer moderators, so the load was spread around. My ex-wife Erin and I were also active in the forums, so we could field these types of questions or concerns when they came up. We didn’t necessarily see it as a problem, just a routine part of managing an online community.

The reason I use the admin baiting label is that from an admin perspective, there’s a sense of obligation to personally reply. You want to be helpful to community members, including answering questions and addressing concerns. But those good intentions can really trap you sometimes, even when you can see the nature of the trap well in advance.

For many instances of admin baiting, a quick reply or two is all it takes to handle the request – no big deal. But what if the matter is contentious? What if other members have different opinions about the initial post? What if you can predict that it would lead to a complex discussion, and you’d rather not take the time to engage in that? That’s where it begins to feel like you’ve been baited into a potential time and energy sink. Have you ever taken the bait and felt icky about it afterwards?

What if you simply ignore such requests? Community members may not like that. You may not like it either. Some may start trying to answer on your behalf, with posts that start with, “Maybe they …” or “Maybe it’s because …” Some members may post false or misleading answers – it happens. Members could even start debating with each other about it, right in front of you. If you wait too long, members may start posting conspiracy theories to explain your silence.

If you give a quick, short reply, some members may be unsatisfied with it, concluding that you’re being illusive. They may ask more follow-up questions, which only draws more attention to the discussion, inviting even more replies from other members. And if you reply to those, you may invite even more.

On the other hand, if you provide a long answer, trying to dispatch with the issue in a single reply, you actually give people more hooks to latch onto for asking more follow-up questions and/or debating with you.

How this plays out will differ greatly from group to group, but it’s easy for it to appear that you have no good options. As soon as a member posts the initial admin baiting message, you may feel that you have little choice but to take the bait, even if you can predict that there will be negative effects without much upside, like stirring up a lot of drama.

I’ve experienced this dynamic in Conscious Growth Club as well, ever since we started in 2017. In the beginning, having open discussions about the administrative aspects of the group made sense to me. It was a co-creative effort, I maintained a progress log within the group, and these open discussions seemed like a good way to be transparent with members and keep them in the loop. It felt sort of like maintaining a friendly open door policy.

Sometimes it was a bit draining though. I didn’t always want to share information on decisions if I thought people might want to debate it a lot, especially if I was busy with other projects. Sometimes I also felt that people over-stepped in their demands for info, as if they were entitled to interview me about the details whenever a member quit the group or was ejected. More than one I would see an admin baiting post and say to myself, “Oh great… this is going to lead to some drama for a few days.”

I adapted as best I could. I learned to detach emotionally, answer honestly, and let such discussions run their course. I got used to dealing with all sorts of member dynamics. I’ve a lot of practice since I’ve been involved in online communities since 1994, including founding a few of them. I’ve spent well over 10 years of my life as the head admin of one community or another. For some reason though, it took me a really long time to feel like I really understood admin baiting and why it can be so problematic. Basically I dealt with so much of it that I developed strong coping skills over a period of years without stopping to question the framing behind the issue.

Recently there was another round of this in CGC, which led to days of discussion and many dozens of posts, and some members still consider it unresolved to their satisfaction. Along the way I kept feeling that there was something entirely wrong with this approach.

I’m not entirely sure if this is related, but I’m also doing a 31-day dietary experiment this month – no grains, no legumes/beans, and no sugar for the month of August. I often experience improvements in mental and emotional clarity when I experiment with more restrictive diets. So it’s possible that this was a contributing factor to seeing the problem from a different perspective.

Eventually this question popped into my mind, and it was a game-changer for me:

Is it reasonable for members to assume the right to engage in admin baiting by posting a question, challenge, or demand related to community policies or admin decisions within the community forums, and thereby to obligate me (or any staff member) to answer them?

What do you think? Do you think that’s a reasonable privilege that a community member should have? Think about it. What’s your honest opinion on this?

Even though this privilege isn’t explicitly granted or promised, I think a lot of community members assume that it’s reasonable. They may even feel it’s unreasonable to be told otherwise. And so they may engage in the practice without even giving it much thought. It’s not unlike sending an email, right?

But if I were to ask other community managers or entrepreneurs this particular question, I think more of them would shake their heads and recognize just how unreasonable it is. It’s a disempowering obligation.

That’s when I finally realized – this assumption isn’t reasonable at all. It’s actually a ridiculously unreasonable expectation that anyone in the community should be able to assert the right to bind me to a potentially time-consuming group discussion – any time they want, as often as they want.

Note that this is entirely different from one-on-one communication, like sending someone an email. Expecting decent customer service does seem reasonable – privately.

This problem can easily creep up on admins in a slippery slope manner. Many admin-related questions are no problem to answer publicly in a forum setting. Some are just a little more complex but still easily dispatched. But every now and then, usually at random intervals, a more complex or contentious case of admin baiting can occur, and now you’re looking at many hours of work – and potentially some community drama – if you accept that invite.

Do you, as a community admin, have the freedom to say no to such invitations? Can’t you just decline, especially when you can clearly see the downsides of getting involved?

Well, how would you do that, assuming you care about maintaining a quality community with a positive and mutually supportive culture?

Will it work if you ignore it? No, we covered that already. In many cases that will make it worse.

Will it work if you reply, “No comment” or equivalent? Probably not since some members may interpret that as meaning that you have something to hide.

The problem is actually upstream. Once someone has engaged in admin baiting, your good options are limited, and they all require some time investment – time that could be better spent elsewhere.

Admin baiting is like going to a party at someone’s house, and sometime during the party, you click your glass to get everyone’s attention, and then you ask the host a question, or you challenge the host to explain something, or you demand that the host change or fix something at the party. You’ve effectively baited the host into having to respond, not just to you but now to everyone in the room. And no matter what kind of reply the host gives, anyone else in the room may assert the right to continue discussing, debating with, or interviewing the host. This could last for a minute… or 10 minutes… or the rest of the evening. The host never really had a good option after being put on the spot, and their ability to engage with the party the way they’d have preferred was derailed to some extent.

For in-person settings like a party or live event, this kind of behavior is typically considered a bit obnoxious except in certain limited settings. But people tend to think differently about online communities. They don’t see all the other people while looking at a forum window, so the social cues aren’t the same.

Within the past several days, I pondered how to solve this problem. I still want to serve community members. I still like being able to provide some transparency. Is there a win-win solution that would serve the same purpose without the practice of admin baiting?

If we take admin baiting off the table, what could we do instead? I think the basic solution looks like this (and “thank you” to the friend who suggested this phrasing):

Take it outside.

In other words, handle administrative issues privately, via one-on-one communication such as email or private messages. Don’t handle them within the community space in front of all of the other members.

Such interactions are likely to be faster and shorter, and they don’t clutter the community with admin-related discussions (especially lengthy ones).

Admin baiting often turns into member baiting as well. Generally speaking members usually prefer to engage with a community on the basis of the community’s core focus and purpose. But if an admin-related discussion arises, especially a complex or contentious one, it can easily draw other members into the discussion, even though they’d probably be better served by focusing on other discussions instead.

An issue that a few members care enough about to engage in a private exchange with an admin could blow up to rope in 3x, 5x, or 10x as many members if discussed openly in the community space. That potentially creates a lot more burden for both the admins and the members.

Now if an admin sees that multiple members are having the same sort of requests through private interactions, the admin can disseminate relevant information more widely, such as by adding an item to a FAQ or by sending out a group email. But in that case it’s a choice – an option – not an immediate obligation.

I saw many other potential benefits to the removal of admin baiting, including better focus for the community, fewer distractions, better community morale, and more value for the members. Consequently, I’ve opted to test this approach in CGC. Yesterday I updated our member rules and guidelines to prohibit admin baiting in the community, steering members to handle admin-related items through private communication, including admin-related questions, sharing feedback on decisions, and more.

It’s barely been 24 hours, and I’m already seeing benefits from this approach. For starters, it’s predictable that this will save a lot of time, energy, and angst down the road. My wife Rachelle is our Community Manager, and she’s also pleased with this change since it makes her job much easier too.

Secondly, the initial feedback and questions that are coming through privately have been thoughtful, useful, and actionable. I like that communicating with a member one-on-one feels more intimate than doing it in the public space of the community forums. I can focus more intently on one person’s questions, comments, or concerns instead of seeing a long page of mixed messaging to decipher.

I can understand that some members may see this as a move away from transparency because we won’t be having open discussions about admin policies and decisions in the forums. I thought about that in advance, and my thinking was that this is probably a neutral type of change transparency-wise. It doesn’t limit my ability to share information with the members. It just gives me more options for doing so.

If I really want to do so, I can still invite an open discussion regarding a policy or decision if I think it would be useful and reasonable. So I always have that option; it just isn’t obligatory. I can see some situations where that might be useful and productive.

Also, there’s still the open door for members to share the same types of issues. We’re just handling this communication outside of the community space.

I like quality feedback, especially when it’s actionable. I’m okay with some debating now and then. I like helping customers and CGC members. And gradually I’ve been learning that some communication is much better suited to a private, one-on-one format.

Even when you consider the transparency aspects, it’s easier to be transparent in one-on-one communication, especially when the relationship is high-trust, and you can customize the communication for each person.

In some ways this is similar to the decision I made not to have public comments on my blog. I actually started with having comments when I began blogging in 2004, but I removed that option in 2005 after it reached about 100 comments per day. What happened afterwards was that I received private feedback via email that was much lower in volume and much higher in quality. I found that to be a very positive change, which is why I’ve kept it this way for 15 years now. I have no regrets about that; it still seems like it was a wise change.

Interestingly, people are more likely to add posts to a community discussion than to send a private message about it. A blog post that might have garnered 100 public comments may generate only a few private emails, sometimes none at all. A forum post on an issue that could have generated dozens of replies may generate just a handful of private messages.

You might think there would be a lot of redundancy from having to field the same types of questions and comments privately, but it’s actually the opposite. There’s way more redundancy when discussions are public. When people send private messages, they tend to be more unique and varied. I’m still pondering why that is. Maybe it’s because people are strongly influenced by what they read in a discussion, and it narrows their focus.

I genuinely feel this type of change is better for our members too, although I can understand why it may be harder to see that when the change is still fresh. I imagine that it will take some members a bit of time to get used to it, but I think they’ll grow to like it when they see how much simpler and smoother it is for all involved.

I think it has a lot of promise, but it is reversible, so if for some reason it doesn’t work out, we can always revert back to the old ways if necessary. I’d be reticent to return to the old reality though, and I’m hopeful that this change will prove itself to be an intelligent, win-win solution. It’s also pretty flexible, so if problems arise there are still plenty of ways to tweak it. In fact, if you know of a better approach than what I’ve outlined here, please do let me know about it. I’m still on the lookout for intelligent communication practices for online communities.

Lastly, I want to make it clear that I harbor no resentment towards anyone who has engaged in this practice in any community I’ve managed. It’s the behavioral pattern and its consequences that I’m addressing here. I surely must admit that in some communities, I occasionally engaged in admin baiting too, not seeing it from the admin perspective at the time. Going forward I want to watch out for this pattern within myself and do my best to “take it outside” for matters that would be more gracefully handled in private.

It’s interesting what solutions can emerge when we look at a problem or challenge from multiple angles.

Share Button

Mount Everest summit success rates double, death rate stays the same over last 30 years

As the world’s tallest peak, Mount Everest draws more than 500 climbers each spring to attempt the summit during a small window of favorable conditions on the rugged Himalayan mountain that tops out at just over 29,000 feet.

A new study led by researchers at the University of Washington and the University of California, Davis, finds that the success rate of summiting Mount Everest has doubled in the last three decades, even though the number of climbers has greatly increased, crowding the narrow route through the dangerous “death zone” near the summit. However, the death rate for climbers has hovered unchanged at around 1% since 1990.

The findings were published Aug. 26 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE. They represent the most comprehensive look at success and death rates in the published literature on Everest. The paper also identifies patterns in the characteristics of mountaineers — such as age, sex and prior experience — that might influence their likelihood of summiting or dying during the spring climbing season.

“Mount Everest is still a very dangerous mountain, and climbing it will never become a walk in the park, because it’s way above the limits of what most people can do,” said lead author Raymond Huey, a UW professor emeritus of biology. “Unfortunately, reported statistics of risk on Everest are often inaccurate. By analyzing climbing data, we provide accurate information on the chances of success and on the chances of dying, thereby helping climbers make an informed decision about whether to attempt this great peak.”

These patterns also can help Nepal and China in deciding whether to institute restrictions on climbers such as maximum age or experience level, Huey added.

Huey and colleagues analyzed the success and death rates for all first-time climbers who had a permit to summit Everest during the period of 2006 to 2019. Previously, they applied the same statistical methods to climbers during the period of 1990 to 2005 and, as a result, they were able to compare success and death rates between the two periods.

During 1990 to 2005, more than 2,200 first-time climbers attempted to summit Everest. During 2006 to 2019, that number increased to more than 3,600 climbers. Importantly, the researchers focused on climbers with paid permits, excluding climbers with additional tasks — such as high-altitude porters, photographers and support staff — along with climbers who attempted to summit in other seasons, or who were attempting the summit for the second time or more.

They also excluded a handful of years from the analyses when extreme events such as ice fall avalanches or earthquakes led to cancellations of the climbing season.

Comparisons between the two periods show that:

  • Summit success rates from the first period to the second period have essentially doubled; two-thirds of climbers now reach the summit, verses one-third previously
  • The overall death rate of around 1% hasn’t changed
  • A contemporary 60-year-old climber has the same success rate (about 40%) as a 40-year-old climber in the prior period — i.e., 60 is the new 40
  • A contemporary 60-year-old climber has the about the same death rate (about 2%) as a 48.5-year-old in the earlier period
  • More women are attempting the climb in recent years (14.6%) verses the previous period (9.1%)
  • Women and men had very similar odds of success or death in both periods

The researchers say the doubling of the summit success rate is likely due to a number of factors. Weather forecasting has dramatically improved since the “Into Thin Air” storm of 1996, Huey said, giving climbers more information on the best window to push for the summit. Some climbers are using elevated flow rates of supplemental oxygen — and doing so lower on the mountain. The most popular routes have fixed lines, meaning climbers can clip into ropes tethered to the mountain for their ascent and descent, making it safer if they fall.

Increased experience of expedition leaders and high-altitude porters may also have helped boost success rates. Interestingly, while more climbers are making it to the top in recent years, today’s climbers are actually less experienced in climbing tall peaks in Nepal than climbers who attempted Everest in the 1990s and early 2000s.

Finally, the researchers looked at the effects of crowding near the summit for the past two climbing seasons (permits were not issued in spring of 2020 because of COVID-19). Detecting possible effects of crowding is difficult with available information, they said, but their analysis didn’t show any impacts of crowding on success or death rates. However, crowding must slow climbers, increasing their exposure in the death zone, they added.

The data for these analyses came from The Himalayan Database, a comprehensive website based on archival interview records of Elizabeth Hawley. Hawley, a news correspondent for Reuters based in Kathmandu, and originally from Chicago, maintained the official record of all climbers and summit successes for Everest and hundreds of other Nepalese peaks until she died several years ago. The project continues under new leadership.

“It’s a remarkable data source,” Huey said. “She was legendary — climbers used to say you have not climbed Mount Everest until Ms. Hawley says you’ve climbed Mount Everest.”

Share Button

How cold was the ice age? Researchers now know

A University of Arizona-led team has nailed down the temperature of the last ice age — the Last Glacial Maximum of 20,000 years ago — to about 46 degrees Fahrenheit.

Their findings allow climate scientists to better understand the relationship between today’s rising levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide — a major greenhouse gas — and average global temperature.

The Last Glacial Maximum, or LGM, was a frigid period when huge glaciers covered about half of North America, Europe and South America and many parts of Asia, while flora and fauna that were adapted to the cold thrived.

“We have a lot of data about this time period because it has been studied for so long,” said Jessica Tierney, associate professor in the UArizona Department of Geosciences. “But one question science has long wanted answers to is simple: How cold was the ice age?”

Tracking Temperature

Tierney is lead author of a paper published today in Nature that found that the average global temperature of the ice age was 6 degrees Celsius (11 F) cooler than today. For context, the average global temperature of the 20th century was 14 C (57 F).

“In your own personal experience that might not sound like a big difference, but, in fact, it’s a huge change,” Tierney said.

She and her team also created maps to illustrate how temperature differences varied in specific regions across the globe.

“In North America and Europe, the most northern parts were covered in ice and were extremely cold. Even here in Arizona, there was big cooling,” Tierney said. “But the biggest cooling was in high latitudes, such as the Arctic, where it was about 14 C (25 F) colder than today.”

Their findings fit with scientific understanding of how Earth’s poles react to temperature changes.

“Climate models predict that the high latitudes will get warmer faster than low latitudes,” Tierney said. “When you look at future projections, it gets really warm over the Arctic. That’s referred to as polar amplification. Similarly, during the LGM, we find the reverse pattern. Higher latitudes are just more sensitive to climate change and will remain so going forward.”

Counting Carbon

Knowing the temperature of the ice age matters because it is used to calculate climate sensitivity, meaning how much the global temperature shifts in response to atmospheric carbon.

Tierney and her team determined that for every doubling of atmospheric carbon, global temperature should increase by 3.4 C (6.1 F), which is in the middle of the range predicted by the latest generation of climate models (1.8 to 5.6 C).

Atmospheric carbon dioxide levels during the ice age were about 180 parts per million, which is very low. Before the Industrial Revolution, levels rose to about 280 parts per million, and today they’ve reached 415 parts per million.

“The Paris Agreement wanted to keep global warming to no larger than 2.7 F (1.5 C) over pre-industrial levels, but with carbon dioxide levels increasing the way they are, it would be extremely difficult to avoid more than 3.6 F (2 C) of warming,” Tierney said. “We already have about 2 F (1.1 C) under our belt, but the less warm we get the better, because the Earth system really does respond to changes in carbon dioxide.”

Making a Model

Since there were no thermometers in the ice age, Tierney and her team developed models to translate data collected from ocean plankton fossils into sea-surface temperatures. They then combined the fossil data with climate model simulations of the LGM using a technique called data assimilation, which is used in weather forecasting.

“What happens in a weather office is they measure the temperature, pressure, humidity and use these measurements to update a forecasting model and predict the weather,” Tierney said. “Here, we use the Boulder, Colorado-based National Center for Atmospheric Research climate model to produce a hindcast of the LGM, and then we update this hindcast with the actual data to predict what the climate was like.”

In the future, Tierney and her team plan to use the same technique to recreate warm periods in Earth’s past.

“If we can reconstruct past warm climates,” she said, “then we can start to answer important questions about how the Earth reacts to really high carbon dioxide levels, and improve our understanding of what future climate change might hold.”

The research was supported by the Heisings-Simons Foundation and the National Science Foundation.

Share Button