New study estimates the odds of life and intelligence emerging beyond our planet

Humans have been wondering whether we alone in the universe since antiquity.

We know from the geological record that life started relatively quickly, as soon our planet’s environment was stable enough to support it. We also know that the first multicellular organism, which eventually produced today’s technological civilization, took far longer to evolve, approximately 4 billion years.

But despite knowing when life first appeared on Earth, scientists still do not understand how life occurred, which has important implications for the likelihood of finding life elsewhere in the universe.

In a new paper published in the Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences today, David Kipping, an assistant professor in Columbia’s Department of Astronomy, shows how an analysis using a statistical technique called Bayesian inference could shed light on how complex extraterrestrial life might evolve in alien worlds.

“The rapid emergence of life and the late evolution of humanity, in the context of the timeline of evolution, are certainly suggestive,” Kipping said. “But in this study it’s possible to actually quantify what the facts tell us.”

To conduct his analysis, Kipping used the chronology of the earliest evidence for life and the evolution of humanity. He asked how often we would expect life and intelligence to re-emerge if Earth’s history were to repeat, re-running the clock over and over again.

He framed the problem in terms of four possible answers: Life is common and often develops intelligence, life is rare but often develops intelligence, life is common and rarely develops intelligence and, finally, life is rare and rarely develops intelligence.

This method of Bayesian statistical inference — used to update the probability for a hypothesis as evidence or information becomes available — states prior beliefs about the system being modeled, which are then combined with data to cast probabilities of outcomes.

“The technique is akin to betting odds,” Kipping said. “It encourages the repeated testing of new evidence against your position, in essence a positive feedback loop of refining your estimates of likelihood of an event.”

From these four hypotheses, Kipping used Bayesian mathematical formulas to weigh the models against one another. “In Bayesian inference, prior probability distributions always need to be selected,” Kipping said. “But a key result here is that when one compares the rare-life versus common-life scenarios, the common-life scenario is always at least nine times more likely than the rare one.”

The analysis is based on evidence that life emerged within 300 million years of the formation of the Earth’s oceans as found in carbon-13-depleted zircon deposits, a very fast start in the context of Earth’s lifetime. Kipping emphasizes that the ratio is at least 9:1 or higher, depending on the true value of how often intelligence develops.

Kipping’s conclusion is that if planets with similar conditions and evolutionary time lines to Earth are common, then the analysis suggests that life should have little problem spontaneously emerging on other planets. And what are the odds that these extraterrestrial lives could be complex, differentiated and intelligent? Here, Kipping’s inquiry is less assured, finding just 3:2 odds in favor of intelligent life.

This result stems from humanity’s relatively late appearance in Earth’s habitable window, suggesting that its development was neither an easy nor ensured process. “If we played Earth’s history again, the emergence of intelligence is actually somewhat unlikely,” he said.

Kipping points out that the odds in the study aren’t overwhelming, being quite close to 50:50, and the findings should be treated as no more than a gentle nudge toward a hypothesis.

“The analysis can’t provide certainties or guarantees, only statistical probabilities based on what happened here on Earth,” Kipping said. “Yet encouragingly, the case for a universe teeming with life emerges as the favored bet. The search for intelligent life in worlds beyond Earth should be by no means discouraged.”

Story Source:

Materials provided by Columbia University. Original written by Carla Cantor. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Share Button

Coronavirus symptoms: UK adds loss of smell and taste to list

Loss of smell and taste join a new cough and fever as signs that self-isolation may be necessary, experts say.

Share Button

Health24.com | Spraying disinfectants can be ‘harmful’, says WHO

Spraying disinfectant on the streets, as practised in some countries, does not eliminate the new coronavirus and even poses a health risk, the World Health Organization (WHO) warned.

In a document on cleaning and disinfecting surfaces as part of the response to the virus, the WHO says spraying can be ineffective.

“Spraying or fumigation of outdoor spaces, such as streets or marketplaces, is… not recommended to kill the Covid-19 virus or other pathogens because disinfectant is inactivated by dirt and debris,” explains the WHO.

“Even in the absence of organic matter, chemical spraying is unlikely to adequately cover all surfaces for the duration of the required contact time needed to inactivate pathogens.”

Physically and psychologically harmful

The WHO said that streets and pavements are not considered as “reservoirs of infection” of Covid-19, adding that spraying disinfectants, even outside, can be “dangerous for human health”.

The document also stresses that spraying individuals with disinfectants is “not recommended under any circumstances”.

“This could be physically and psychologically harmful and would not reduce an infected person’s ability to spread the virus through droplets or contact,” said the document.

Spraying chlorine or other toxic chemicals on people can cause eye and skin irritation, bronchospasm and gastrointestinal effects, it adds.

The organisation is also warning against the systematic spraying and fumigating of disinfectants on to surfaces in indoor spaces, citing a study that has shown it to be ineffective outside direct spraying areas.

Recorded under laboratory conditions

“If disinfectants are to be applied, this should be done with a cloth or wipe that has been soaked in disinfectant,” it says.

The SARS-CoV-2 virus, the cause of the pandemic that has killed more than 300 000 people worldwide since its appearance in late December in China, can attach itself to surfaces and objects.

However, no precise information is currently available for the period during which the viruses remain infectious on the various surfaces.

Studies have shown that the virus can stay on several types of surfaces for several days. However, these maximum durations are only theoretical because they are recorded under laboratory conditions and should be “interpreted with caution” in the real-world environment.

Image credit:

Share Button

Coronavirus: Global push for inquiry into Covid-19 response

Health leaders are set to meet amid scrutiny of the WHO’s handling of the crisis and US-China tensions.

Share Button

Health24.com | Dogs may catch coronavirus from owners, but won’t infect humans

Panic ensued earlier during the coronavirus pandemic when cases of dogs testing positive for SARS-CoV-2 were reported in Hong Kong.

Animal shelters and rescue organisations worldwide had to plead that owners don’t abandon their dogs, as dogs cannot spread the virus to humans.

Now, researchers who studied the genomic link suspect that the infection was passed from owner to dog, according to Malik Peiris, a virologist at the University of Hong Kong, and main author of the study published in the journal Nature.

There was no evidence that dogs could pass the infection to other dogs or people, but Peiris stated that they needed to consider every possibility. 

According to Arjan Stegeman, a veterinary epidemiologist at Utrecht University in the Netherlands, it’s unlikely that people with Covid-19 will infect their dogs, even though the studies show it might be possible.

Other scientists, however, did report to Nature that pets might be able to spread the virus among each other, and that this risk needed to be researched for management in future outbreaks.

Should owners diagnosed with Covid-19 worry about their pets?

While more research is needed to ascertain the extent of owners infecting their pets, the American Veterinary Medical Association urges people to take some precautions. They advise patients with Covid-19 who are recovering at home to wear a mask when caring for their pets and should avoid petting, hugging or kissing their animals while sick. They should also wash their hands before and after contact with their pets.

Animals and Covid-19

According to Jürgen Richt, a veterinary virologist at Kansas State University in Manhattan, research is not only imperative to protect animals from getting sick, but to see exactly how animals such as working animals and livestock can potentially spread the virus in a community.

Rich also stated that more research is needed to see if pets experience any symptoms.

He is particularly worried that this may lead to more owners abandoning their animals in fear.

For now, it’s best to be informed, to understand that the probability of your dog or cat catching the virus is low, and simply to be aware of your animals’ health, and to contact your vet if are any changes in their health.

Image credit: iStock 

Share Button

Health24.com | OPINION | Enhancing the healthcare value chain during COVID-19

A shock to the system

Whether we should have been or not is up for debate, but when Covid-19 began its rapid spread across the globe we were shocked. Taken by surprise, we found we didn’t have nearly enough of what we needed to defend ourselves against the scale of this silent killer: resources, masks, ventilators, hospital beds, time. And so governments and health professionals around the world began the grim, morally fraught, emotionally wearying business of health risk triage: allocating resources, attention, time, equipment in a way that would do the most good, or the least harm. 

As we enter into the second phase of our response to the pandemic, in which we reckon with the persistence of the infections, the lack of vaccines, and the ongoing behavioural responses that we’re going to need to make, we’re involved in triage on a different scale, judging prevention of the spread of the disease against its ongoing, devastating economic and social impact. 

It is important, as we make these decisions, to be aware of their long-term impact, to make sure our decisions and motivations in healthcare are data- and evidence-based, and to consider both the demand and supply sides of the healthcare value chain. Value in healthcare is defined as health outcomes that matter to patients relative to the cost of achieving those outcomes. There are gaps within the current healthcare value chain that can be addressed in a meaningful way to make the system as a whole more efficient. 

Filling the gaps

Increased digitisation of the healthcare value chain and the measuring of patient outcomes have been vital components for creating more efficient healthcare systems, but we haven’t had the impetus or available investments to implement this at scale. Covid-19 has been somewhat of a catalyst for the deployment of digital healthcare solutions that allow patients to interact with the healthcare system in a more coordinated and meaningful way.

What is critical now is to have a system that allows us to appropriately screen, report, treat and channel patients based on the care they require without overburdening the healthcare system. Predictive modelling, based on available data, is crucial in order to anticipate which facilities will be required to provide services, and then to direct patients accordingly.

In an environment of persistent, phased lockdown, we will presumably move in and out of scaled restrictions on our free movement. In this context, you also need to have an early warning system that can facilitate remote interactions and verifications between patients, pharmacies and healthcare professionals. 

A digitised, trustworthy system allows patients to consult with health professionals via video-led technology and receive prescriptions without visiting the practitioner. Healthcare regulations are a vital enabler for innovative digital healthcare solutions to positively impact the demand and supply sides of healthcare. Digital electronic signatures facilitate e-scripting to pharmacies and referrals among healthcare providers. Patients could have a consultation with a healthcare professional, the script could be issued to a pharmacy, and the medication could be safely delivered to the patient’s doorstep without them leaving their home. 

Most importantly, vulnerable individuals, i.e. the elderly, the immunocompromised and people with co-morbidity need to be able to self-report via remote monitoring systems. These systems would allow healthcare professionals to effectively triage patients, and healthcare facilities would be able to deal with the more acute, serious cases without exposing patients with less severe conditions to the dangers of infection. 

Remote solutions

Healthcare resource allocation will increasingly be managed in terms of infection hotspots. Data management is crucial during this crisis and the South African government has been very responsive in terms of monitoring communities and identifying those hotspot areas. We will need the aggressive continuation of data collection and risk assessment to rapidly identify at-risk communities and prevent flareups.

This requires significant resources in itself, especially given the remoteness of some areas of South Africa. Crisis management systems, communications platforms, and remote support for healthcare workers all need to be rolled out evenly, not just focusing on urban centres. Messaging around behaviours required to prevent infection have to be consistent, clear, credible, and expanded so that remote areas are educated and informed. The more you create a trusted communication environment for communities, the more empowered and informed they are to make the right decisions.

The same is true in terms of the response of corporate South Africa. Certainty around which measures to take – and to invest resources in to protect employees and clients – at each stage of our evolving response to the pandemic will prevent missteps and misallocation of funding. 

A clear set of protocols to guide the response of corporate South Africa, outlining the minimum effective standards (as set by government and the WHO) would need to be implemented and followed as lockdown restrictions ease. 

I work for a company that specialises in technology and healthcare infrastructure design solutions. My colleagues across the EOH group have been hard at work over the last two months and have made some incredible strides in very little time, rolling out digital solutions such as thermal temperature scanning devices; patient referral and billing systems; eScripting solutions; fully equipped ICUlate mobile ICU and isolation units deployable in both rural and urban areas; the reconfiguring of dental practices with effective extraction systems for Covid-19 risks; crisis management communication apps that monitor employee check-ins, office capacity and the health risk of a workforce returning to service; and new digital channels for remote servicing of clients now and well beyond the pandemic.

Technology, as an enabler for a more efficient healthcare value chain, could facilitate the required outcomes which are so desperately required to effectively navigate and deliver immense patient value during the Covid-19 crisis.

*Milton Streak is a former Executive Principal Officer of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme, and is currently an Executive at NEXTEC, one of the two operating subsidiaries of the EOH Group.

Image credit: Photo supplied

Share Button

Coronavirus: Half a million access suicide prevention course

It comes as medics warn the coronavirus pandemic is likely to lead to long-term mental health conditions.

Share Button

Coronavirus: UK daily death figure dips to lowest since day after lockdown

The government says if a vaccine trial is successful the UK will have 30 million doses by September.

Share Button

Generative Learning

Generative learning is when you generate your own solutions to a problem or challenge, get feedback from reality, and learn from your mistakes.

This is similar to the evolutionary development model of software development, whereby you do some coding, play around with your app, and then evolve it some more.

Contrast this with learning solutions from other people. The limitation here is that other people’s solved problems probably don’t perfectly match your current problems.

When I was building my computer games business, I often came up short when trying to apply other people’s advice. They didn’t know my skills and talents. They didn’t know my concerns and limitations. Consequently, their advice would often land flat with me.

I had a similar experience when I was in a $30K per year business mastermind group in 2018. We’d do some masterminding sessions, and I’d often walk away with a collection of advice from other people that made little sense for my situation. People shared what worked for them, not what would work for me. What others advised usually didn’t align with my values, skills, customers, business model, or much else about my business. I often found it more practical to bounce ideas around with my wife.

It’s still nice to mastermind with other people, but not because their ready-made solutions will work. Masterminding is good for stimulating you to do your own experiments and explorations. I found it better for the vibe and the encouragement. The actual business advice was weak and misguided.

Where I tend to get the best results in life is from generative learning. It’s basically trial and error with a fancier name. As simple and effective as this is, people still don’t do enough of it.

It’s hard to come up with good business models that check all the boxes: lucrative, sustainable, personally fulfilling, purposeful, achievable, ambitious, fun, etc. If you apply someone else’s ready-made business model, you’ll probably feel some resistance in applying it to your own life. I think that’s because deep down, you know it’s a bit off. It’s a mismatch for you. Some people can do it, but you have to be really obedient, and many people just aren’t.

Someone else’s model can serve as a starting point for exploration, but there’s no substitute for doing the actual exploration work. Keep generating and testing your own solutions to problems.

When I look at advice on diet and nutrition, I can’t find anyone who teaches how I actually eat.

When I look at other people’s businesses, I can’t find anyone who teaches how to build and run a business like mine.

In all the relationship books I’ve read, I haven’t found any that describe how I relate to people.

I don’t know of anyone else teaching the philosophy of life that actually works for me.

There are lots of people teaching lifestyle design, but none of them teach the lifestyle that works for me.

I like being very organized, but I don’t do organizing like anyone else does. People sometimes ask me if I use some particular system. I can only do my system, not anyone else’s.

I sometimes pick up ideas from other people, but I haven’t allowed anyone to collect me as their protégé. My solutions were all arrived at through generative learning. I experimented till I found what works.

I’m actually pretty happy in my life these days. Even with the coronavirus situation, this has actually been an incredible year for me. One reason is that I’ve been moving quickly through my own forms of generative learning. For instance, the daily blogging serves as a new generative learning experience every day of the year, so my writing can evolve faster. Readers are telling me that I’m doing some of my best work ever this year, but I also think I’m doing some of my worst writing this year. I’m making more mistakes to learn faster.

If I try to directly apply what I’ve learned from other people, it always falls flat. I can’t get myself to do it. It’s always flawed. It’s always missing some key elements that would actually make it work for me.

But generative learning – good old trial and error – that’s been the most reliable path to finding solutions.

The “error” part sucks because who wants to fail? But if we can embrace the suckiness of that and know that it leads to more personalized, effective solutions, it’s easier to stomach it.

How are you personally responding to the coronavirus situation? Are you handling this situation as someone else taught you? Or are you finding your own way through this? I’ll bet you’ll get the best results by figuring out your own approach. Who else is capable to telling you how to intelligently reshape your life during these times? Only you can do that.

Let reality be the judge. Reality will show you whether your solutions are effective or not. If your solutions fall flat, accept that. I hate it when a solution that looks beautiful in the planning phase gets a failing grade from the real world. But I also know that it’s just feedback. It’s part of the learning process. And so I go back to the drawing board and try something else, just as optimistic as the previous time. I’m optimistic because I know that generative learning works in the long run.

What would happen if you embraced personal responsibility for generating your own solutions to life’s problems instead of trying to learn solutions from others? What if devising and testing solutions was 100% on you? What if no one would ever give you any advice? What if you couldn’t read or research to find any solutions?

How would you go about solving some of your problems, relying only on your existing knowledge and skills and good old trial and error? What if your only main problem solving tool was generative learning?

I’d bet that if you leaned more heavily on this tool, you could go faster. You’d stop waiting for other people to teach you things, and you’d come up with your own solutions. Some of your ideas won’t work, and you’ll learn from them. The more you explore and experiment, the sooner you’ll find what does work – for you.

Other people won’t solve your problems for you, but social support is still immensely valuable. Social support is good for generating ideas for experiments to do. It’s good for emotional encouragement. It’s good for pushing you to think bigger and to amp up your ambition. It’s good for pointing out shortcomings in your approaches. It’s good for opportunity abundance. But don’t regard other people as a pathways to fast and easy, ready-made solutions. You’re the ultimate problem solver in your life.

Share Button

Health24.com | What it’s like: Heading up Charlotte Maxeke’s emergency department in the time of Covid-19

From 1 May 2020, it became mandatory for every person in the country to wear a mask in public. For hospital staff like doctors and nurses, however, wearing masks and personal protective equipment (PPE) has always been the norm even before the first Covid-19 case was confirmed in South Africa.

Medical staff have been donning and doffing – the practice of employees putting on and removing work-related protective gear, clothing, and uniforms – daily. Having to manage infection control in hospitals is after all nothing new.

They are not only treating Covid-19 cases, but are also attending to the ‘normal’ patients, who are placed in separate areas of the hospital, explains Professor Feroza Motara, head of the emergency department at Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital (CMJAH).

“You have to wear the full PPE to protect yourself – which includes the helmet. There is a lot of donning – to put on (the clothing) and doffing (to take off the protective clothing) in between seeing patients,” says Motara.

“The full PPE is very hot and uncomfortable to wear when you wear it for long periods. It’s not heavy but it’s hot.”Motara says she feels protected when she wears her PPE.

“We have enough protective equipment. It will be a challenge if numbers go up significantly.”

PPE problems

Limited stock of personal protective equipment PPE, particularly N95 masks, has been a problem in many countries. At times in the United Kingdom doctors have resorted to wearing a surgical mask (not as protective as an N95).

In the United States, many healthcare workers have admitted that their biggest concern is that they will not have enough personal protective equipment to take care of the number of patients that are coming in.

This week the Gauteng Department of Health in a statement said it has 11 004 334 items of PPE stock on hand. Based on the current patient load, the department said this is “adequate” and has procured more.

This include body PPE (gowns), face PPE (masks), hand PPE (gloves), respiratory PPE and tools.Similar fears on PPEs have been expressed in South Africa and it is widely accepted that healthcare workers are at a much higher risk of contracting Covid-19 than the general public.

On Wednesday last week Minister of Health Dr Zweli Mkhize said that 511 healthcare workers in South Africa had by then tested positive for Covid-19.

Of these 26 had been hospitalised and two had passed away at the time. At least one more healthcare worker has died since.Gauteng Department of Health spokesperson Kwara Kekana says they are fortunate that most health workers who tested positive for Covid-19 in the province have not needed hospitalisation.

Less than five months later

The disease that we now know as Covid-19 was first reported less than five months ago in Wuhan, China. On 30 January, the World Health Organization declared the outbreak a Public Health Emergency of International Concern, and on 11 March a pandemic.

Motara remembers how she felt when the Minister of Health announced in February that Charlotte Maxeke would be a designated Covid-19 hospital.

“(It was) scary, and we were anxious when hearing about it as we didn’t know much about the problem,” she says.

In February, Charlotte Maxeke treated its first Covid-19 patient.

“The first patient who was Covid-19 positive was one of the original travellers from the Italian tour group. The patient was stable, and it was a bit scary as we knew so much less than we know now,” says Motara.

“But the patient was managed as any other patient, was treated and discharged within a week.”

South Africa reported its first Covid-19 positive case on 5 March. According to a statement by Mkhize at the time, it was a “38-year-old male who travelled to Italy with his wife”.

The two were part of a tour group of 10 people who visited Italy and arrived back on 1 March – the same tour group as the patient in CMJAH.

Many changes

Motara says that these days the atmosphere at the hospital is more stressful. “Staff are concerned about potential infection and about taking it home to their families,” she says.

While she says that there was little psycho-social support in the beginning, there are now support groups and staff are offered therapy. Staff are also closely monitored for potential Covid-19 infection.

Much has also changed in how the hospital is run. Weekends used to be busy for her unit, Motara explains. [Before lockdown] there were more trauma related cases because of increased alcohol intake.

“Presently we have added a load of Covid-19 related illnesses in addition to the normal patient load.”

She says the lockdown and the alcohol ban now means that there are “almost no trauma cases, no accidents from drunken driving, no violent fights with knives and guns”.

Kekana points out that facilities in the province have now set up triage areas outside for screening, and those presenting with flu-like symptoms are then handled accordingly based on assessment.

Inside the hospital care is also taken to keep Covid-19 patients apart from other patients.

“The medical emergency unit sees all patients but patients are now screened for Covid-19 as they enter the unit and are then separated into different areas for Covid-19 and non-Covid-19.(There is) no effect on non-Covid-19 patients as they are still seen in a separate area,” Motara explains.

“Practice has changed – now there is much more awareness of infection risk, we’re taking additional protective measures – masks, gloves, aprons, visors,” she says. “When entering area where the Covid-19 patients are, one has to take all the precautions.”

By 13 May a cumulative total of 303 Covid-19 positive patients were admitted to hospitals in Gauteng. According to a statement of the provincial health department, a cumulative number of 231 patients were discharged and 24 succumbed to Covid-19.

There are currently 48 patients being treated for Covid-19 in Gauteng hospitals.

“(It is) a bit daunting and anxious but hopefully our preparation has enabled us to deal with what’s coming,” says Motara when asked about the expected surge in Covid-19 cases.

“We have put protocols in place and chains for command regarding who gets intubated and when. These are based on evidence from overseas areas that had high numbers of patients.”

‘The greatest reward’

Motara started working as a doctor in 1991.

“I graduated from Wits University, worked as an intern at the then Johannesburg General Hospital just after it had opened up for non-white staff to be employed there,” she says.

Thirteen years later in 2004 she became the head of the emergency department at Charlotte Maxeke.

She grew up in Mbombela (Nelspruit).Motara says she became a doctor because she has always had a passion for helping others.

“(I’m) trying to do good for more than myself. I feel I can make a difference in people’s lives and communities,” she says.“Helping a gogo who is ill or a child lying at death’s door is the greatest reward for what I do.”

But with Covid-19 comes new risks.“My family are concerned about my risk and exposure and I’m concerned about potentially exposing them if I get infected,” she says.

Motara sees her two children daily but cannot see her mother or extended family. “(I) need to protect my elderly mum from any risk – but we talk over the phone or social media.

My children are old enough to understand,” she says, “so they know the risks. Although they are coping well, they are worried about me.”

*This article was produced by Spotlight – health journalism in the public interest. Sign up for our newsletter and stay informed.

Image credit: Photo supplied

Share Button