Exploding Your Mindset Box

Some of the biggest traps in self-development are mindset traps, usually because they’re invisible to us. We get ourselves into a mindset box but can’t see the walls.

What if the mindset box you’re in doesn’t contain any solutions to your biggest problems? What if those answers exist only outside the box?

A common symptom of this trap is when you think you’ve tried just about everything and still aren’t getting results in a particular area. This is often true of financial, career, relationship, and health challenges.

What you’ve really done is tried many solutions that are accessible within the same mindset box. None of them have worked for you because the mindset box itself is the problem.

For instance, one mindset box is the self-absorption box that I shared in yesterday’s post. When you’re in this box, you frame your problems self-referentially, as if the whole world revolves around you. While that can be an empowering frame for some types of problems, it’s especially weak for overcoming with financial and relationship challenges. Consequently, you’ll often find self-absorbed people struggling with their finances and relationships. And they’re usually blind to how much the self-absorption mindset is limiting them.

Would you want to be in a relationship with someone who’s highly self-absorbed and has a hard time considering other people’s perspectives? Would you want to do business with such a person? When you look at this mindset box from the outside, its limitations become apparent, but when you’re inside the box, you probably won’t realize that the mindset itself is the problem.

This is a key point to understand. You’re in your own mindset box right now, and it’s limiting you. Moreover, you can’t even see how it’s limiting you. What you can see, however, is your frustrating lack of results in a particular area.

Consider some area of your life that stubbornly refuses to progress towards greater results, no matter how much you work on it. Now ask yourself this: How could your own mindset box could be preventing you from making progress? Ask yourself what other mindsets people use to get results in this area. Consider how someone with a different mindset might approach this problem.

Most importantly, test different behaviors that conflict or disagree with your current mindset. Play with them by taking actions that you’d only take if you adopted an opposing mindset. You don’t have to agree with a mindset to test its behaviors. New behaviors can generate new results for you, even if you still vehemently disagree with the mindset behind that behavior.

Which behaviors have you rejected because they don’t agree with your current mindset box? Try some of those behaviors, and see where they lead. This is how you can start exploring beyond your mindset box.

A key limiting belief to overcome here is that you can only test actions and behaviors that align with your current mindset box. That isn’t true at all. You’re free to test behaviors that conflict with your mindset. Your ability to take action isn’t beholden to obey any particular mindset. Behaviors stem from thoughts, and mindsets stem from thoughts, and those thoughts needn’t agree with each other. Your brain is plenty big enough to hold space for opposing thoughts.

So be deliberately disagreeable with the mindset that’s generating behaviors that aren’t getting results for you. Be disobedient. Be willing to explore in direct violation of that mindset.

For instance, if you have a neediness or a self-absorption mindset, those mindsets are traps that will limit your results. What behaviors would be in conflict with such mindsets? How about volunteering? If you’re needy or self-absorbed, you’re not going to volunteer to help others. Only someone who has a mindset of kindness, generosity, or abundance will volunteer their time and energy to help others, right? So this behavior will clearly irritate your neediness or self-absorption mindset. Perfect! That’s exactly what to you ought to do then.

Your old mindset box will raise plenty of objections about why you can’t do a behavior that conflicts with it. Wonderful! Let it object because you have a much bigger counter-objection. Here’s your counter-objection:

Oh yeah… well you suck at getting results!

Let your old mindset chew on that for a while. Now matter how much it whines at you, face it down with the hard truth it doesn’t want to hear: You’re not getting results, old mindset. You’ve repeatedly let us down.

This approach has turned my life around multiple times. I did the volunteering thing when I was broke and going bankrupt. My old mindset objected vehemently, but my attitude was that the old mindset never worked for me anyway, so what did I have to lose by trying something totally different? My finances turned around that same year, and I haven’t had any problems with scarcity since. That was 21 years ago. The old mindset could never solve that problem for me. But a simple new behavior solved it beautifully.

New behaviors will crack your old mindsets that didn’t work, eventually leading you to new mindsets that align with the new behavior. And now you’re outside of the old box, and now your new mindset will generate still more behaviors, and some of those behaviors will help you get better results. Quite often you won’t figure out the new mindset though till you explore the behaviors that lead you to it.

So it’s not always true that your first behavioral exploration outside your old mindset will create breakthrough results, but by cracking the old mindset, you’ll gain access to even more behaviors. You’ll expand the possibility space by tearing down the old walls. This gives you a much better chance of finding and adopting behaviors that generate better results than your old mindset box ever could.

The benefits of exploring beyond my own mindset boxes have been profound. This is a key reason I do so many personal growth experiments that other people would find questionable. I like to explore behaviors that challenge and push the boundaries my mindset box.

Some of these behavioral experiments include:

  • Going to Disneyland for 30 days in a row
  • Eating a low-fat raw diet for 30 days
  • Going skydiving
  • Going vegan
  • Joining Toastmasters and doing speech contests
  • Doing live events on the Vegas Strip
  • Water fasting for 40 days
  • Training for and running a marathon
  • Traveling through Europe for several weeks without paying for a place to stay
  • Doing lots of manifestation experiments
  • Becoming a hugger
  • Going to a cuddle party
  • Learning to play guitar
  • Moving to Las Vegas
  • Learning card counting for blackjack
  • Becoming an early riser
  • Starting a computer games business fresh out of college
  • Seeing 200+ independent theater productions (and assisting in some)
  • Shifting from a fenced relationship to an open relationship
  • Blogging every day for a year (my current one)
  • Inviting and experiencing threesomes
  • Joining the Church of Scientology and going to one of their centers for a few months
  • Going on a 4000-mile road trip
  • Converting to a smart home with cleaning robots, voice-controlled thermostats, and numerous smart devices from Apple, Amazon, and Google
  • Traveling many times with a one-way ticket, not knowing when I’d return
  • Joining an improv troupe for a few months
  • Doing ayahuasca four nights in a row

Did all of these experiments fit neatly into my mindset at the time I tried them? Heck no!

You try walking into a Scientology center without your mind generating a slew of objections. You try showing up at Disneyland with the expectation that you’re going to spend a full month of your life there. You try pulling out your credit card to reserve a meeting room on the Vegas Strip for a 3-day workshop when you’ve never done one before. Of course your mind is going to object when you step outside its boundaries!

I revel in these kinds of experiments though because they keep destroying the walls of old mindset boxes that no longer serve me. Sometimes even a good mindset that generates pleasing results for a while can feel limiting after a while. Maybe you start feeling bored and listless. That’s a good time to mix things up by violating your current mindset with some objectionable behaviors.

One of my next mindset box violations that I want to attempt this year is to write a novel. I’ve never written a novel before, so of course my mind objects to that idea. I have written millions of words of published content, including my nonfiction book Personal Development for Smart People, but fiction feels like a different beast entirely.

So of course my current mindset objects to this idea. What if I write a novel and it absolutely sucks? What if everyone trashes it as the worst piece of crap they’ve ever read? What if it takes way longer than I expect? What if I can’t get the story to converge on a decent ending? Yada yada yada.

When I see objections like that, to me that’s a damned good reason to take action and try out the new behavior. If my old mindset objects so much, then its walls must be feeling vulnerable. Just making the attempt could lead me to some fresh mindset territory. Regardless of how the novel turns out, the path of exploring fiction will be an expansive one.

Probe the limitations of your current mindset. Look for behaviors that your current mindset says you can’t possibly do. Then explore those behaviors anyway. Smash the walls of your old mindset box, and you’ll surely discover more empowering mindsets and behaviors. And don’t stop. Keep smashing!

The key benefit here is that when you violate a limiting mindset, you gain access to new results. Do you want better results, or would you prefer to continue wallowing in freakish misery?

I don’t have to deal with being broke anymore because I smashed down the walls that caused me to get stuck there. I spent most of my 20s behind those walls, but my 30s and 40s were free of them. Have you smashed the walls of brokeness yet? If not, then your current mindset probably sucks and needs to be smashed. So find a behavior that violates that mindset, and go test it for a month or two.

I don’t have to deal with a lack of affection in my life anymore. I smashed those walls too. So I get to enjoy a super affectionate wife who hugs, kisses, and cuddles me every day. Have you smashed the walls of emotional neediness yet? What behavior would violate the old mindset that isn’t getting the job done? Yup, that one!

If I didn’t explore beyond the mindset boxes that limited me, I’d probably still be dealing with crappy, unwanted results in many areas of life. Now whenever I don’t like my results, I have a method for getting past the “I’ve tried everything and none of it works” nonsense.

The best part is that it’s actually fun to do this kind of smashing, once you get used to it. Sometimes it’s fun just to see other people’s reactions. Sometimes it’s exciting thinking about how different life will be for a while. I really enjoyed the 30 days at Disneyland, for instance. Somehow I never got bored, and that experience pushed me to think bigger. I realized that Walt Disney got that whole monstrosity going by stepping into behaviors that made other people think he was crazy. I don’t think I’d have started Conscious Growth Club if I hadn’t done that Disney experiment.

I challenge you to violate a mindset box that limits you. Commit yourself to a course of action that the old mindset box tells you is out of bounds. If the old mindset isn’t generating the results you want anyway, throw that back in its face when it objects. Don’t blame yourself for the lack of results. Blame your old mindset.

When you do this often enough, you’ll start to trust the process more. I know it’s scary the first few times, but that fear is just one more mindset box to blow up. So many awesome results in life can be found on the other side of fear… the other side of worry… the other side of playing small.

Share Button

Health24.com | Newborn may have contracted coronavirus in the womb

A Canadian newborn is a “probable” case of infection with the new coronavirus while still in the womb, doctors report.

Other such cases have been suspected and reported in prior studies. But the mother’s active case of Covid-19, along with the fact that the baby boy was delivered via C-section, add weight to the notion that maternal-foetal transmission of the SARS-CoV-2 virus can occur, the Toronto doctors concluded.

There was good news, however: Although the baby was born preterm (about 36 weeks), he was a healthy 6.5 pounds. And even though testing positive for coronavirus, he did not develop Covid-19.

Still, the case “represents a probable case of congenital SARS-CoV-2 infection in a liveborn neonate,” said researchers led by paediatrician Dr Prakesh Shah, of Toronto’s Mount Sinai Hospital. They published their report on 14 May in the Canadian Medical Association Journal.

‘Semi-urgent’ C-section

As Shah’s group noted, prior studies from China have already confirmed coronavirus infection in newborns born to women infected with the new coronavirus. But it’s been tough to ascertain whether the infant picked up the infection via contact with the vaginal canal during birth, or by being held by the mother, or by breastfeeding.

In the new case, a 40-year-old pregnant woman arrived at the hospital to deliver her baby. She was already suffering from active Covid-19, with body aches, reduced appetite, fatigue, dry cough and a fever of 102 degrees Fahrenheit (38.88 degrees Celsius).

Luckily, she did not require any respiratory support, her doctors said, but it was decided that the woman undergo a “semi-urgent” C-section.

Her baby boy was “vigorous” upon birth and didn’t require any help breathing. However, nasal swab tests conducted at birth, one day after, and then again seven days after, all turned up positive for infection with the new coronavirus.

It’s impossible to confirm that the infant contracted the virus while still in the womb, but Shah’s team wrote that the woman did have reduced immune system function, which would leave her body more vulnerable to the virus.

Infection via the placenta

As well, testing of her placenta revealed inflammation in those tissues that was “consistent with primary viral infection”, the doctors said.

The baby boy had not come in contact with the woman’s vaginal tract during his C-section delivery, and all precautions were taken (masks, gloves etc.) to minimise the spread of coronavirus from mom to newborn in the hours after birth.

So, “we suspect the possibility of a transamniotic route of [coronavirus] infection via the placenta,” the team wrote.

Dr Adi Davidov is associate chair of gynaecology at Staten Island University Hospital in New York City. Reading over the Toronto findings, he said, “This is the first report that clearly shows that there is a small possibility that Covid can be transmitted in utero.”

Davidov added that although people primarily think of SARS-CoV-2 as invading the respiratory tract, “it can occasionally be found in other areas of the body”, and that may include the uterus and placenta.

A rare phenomenon

Still, maternal-foetal transmission of coronavirus probably isn’t common, he believes.

“Given that we have now delivered hundreds of mothers infected with the SARS-CoV-2 and we have not seen this phenomenon, it is pretty safe to assume that this is a rare phenomenon,” Davidov said. “Nonetheless, it is important for clinicians to be aware of this situation and to screen all newborns for Covid-19.”

Shah and his colleagues added that it’s important for health care workers caring for newborns to understand the potential hazard.

“All health care providers attending an infected woman’s delivery and caring for the baby in the NICU should recognise this risk and use appropriate personal protective equipment to prevent droplet, contact and aerosol transmission [of the coronavirus],” they said.

Image credit:

Share Button

Health24.com | Covid-19: More important than ever to know your HIV status

Covid-19, the disease caused by the new coronavirus – officially named SARS-CoV-2 – appears to affect especially the elderly and those with pre-existing chronic conditions and weakened immune systems, including those living with HIV.

That’s why, for those who do not know their HIV status, getting tested is crucial to surviving the Covid-19 virus, says Dr Seithati Molefi, deputy chief of party at healthcare NPO, Right to Care.

“Having a suppressed immune system means your body will not be able to fight Covid-19 effectively. It is critical that you get tested to know your status so that you can start antiretroviral treatment (ART), should you be positive.”

HIV+ and on ART? No need to panic

If you’re living with HIV and are on ART, there’s no need for concern, as currently, you are not at an increased risk and are in fact likely more able to fight Covid-19.

“Patients who have stopped taking their ART are also at risk of severe disease and should ensure that they get back on their medication immediately.”

This stance is backed by infectious diseases specialist, Professor Salim Abdool Karim, who is also director of the Durban-based Centre for the Aids Programme of Research in South Africa and chairs the government’s advisory committee on Covid-19. 

“If an HIV-positive patient is on antiretrovirals, then their response will be pretty similar to what an HIV-negative patient’s response would be based on what we know from other infections,” Karim told Bhekisisa earlier this year. 

Where to go for testing

Healthcare clinics and hospitals are essential services, so should be open for HIV tests, ART refills and all other important health services under any lockdown level, the organisation mentioned.

“Anyone who is seeking medical care during the lockdown will not get into trouble with the authorities, since healthcare is an essential service.  It is also important that everyone continues to take their chronic medication so they are as healthy as possible,” Molefi explained. 

Covid-19 and HIV tests at your home 

Door-to-door Covid-19 screening has been taking place by the Department of Health and the Right to Care during lockdown. If you wish to be tested for HIV (while being screened for HIV), you may ask the healthcare worker as some of the teams offer HIV tests at no cost, and are completely confidential. If, however, they do not have an HIV test, they should be able to organise one for you.

“If you don’t know your HIV status, Right to Care and the Department of Health community counsellors will give you a respectful, free and confidential HIV test wherever you are comfortable: at your nearest facility, in your community or your home, making it easy for you to test, start treatment and stay on treatment.

“If you are in Ehlanzeni District, Mpumalanga or Thabo Mofutsananya District in the Free State and want to test, send a WhatsApp or phone Right to Care’s helpline on 079 851 2490,” explains Dr Chuka Onaga, deputy chief of party in Mpumalanga.

Collecting treatment during lockdown 

The Department of Health CCMDD programme allows patients to collect their medication, including ARVs, from external pick up points. Collect & Go smart lockers, which eliminates queues, are located in communities in Gauteng, Mpumalanga and the Free State, and are operational during the lockdown period. For a complete list of nearby locations, visit their website. 

However, this option is only available to patients with stable conditions who are registered by their healthcare facility. As soon as your medication is ready for collection, you will get a one-time pin via SMS, which can then be used to access the locker and receive your two-month supply of medication.

Treatment cannot be undermined, says Mkhize

Speaking at a WHO Media Briefing on Covid-19 in Africa earlier this month, health minister Dr Zweli Mkhize expressed his concern that over five million people are on ARV treatment in South Africa, and stressed that their treatment programme cannot be undermined.

“That’s going to create a new problem on the side, and as a result of that, therefore, we have encouraged and empowered our community workers to continue the message of the importance of continuing and getting your treatment,” he said.

Mhkize again on Monday raised concerns about people with co-morbidities: “As we prepare for the easing of lockdown regulations high risk age groups and those withco-morbidities such as hypertension, diabetes, cardiac disease, obesity and people living with HIV must take extra precautions and necessary steps to avoid possible exposure to Covid-19.”

Share Button

Health24.com | The many cardiovascular risks of Covid-19 – what research says

Covid-19, the disease caused in humans by the SARS-CoV-2 virus, remains a mystery that needs a lot more unwrapping. 

At first, experts believed that the conditions caused by the novel coronavirus were just respiratory diseases. But as the virus circled the globe, doctors saw a wider range of diseases in their patients, fatal in many cases.  

These complications include heart failure, heart attacks and blood clots, which were all reported by emergency doctors in a new scientific paper.

What the paper entailed

The paper was published in the American Journal of Emergency Medicine.

According to a news release, the paper, published by the University of Virginia’s Health System, draws emergency doctors’ attention to the fact that Covid-19 doesn’t only present with pulmonary complications, but that they should also be on the lookout for cardiovascular symptoms, which may lead to death.

The authors did their research by searching PubMed and Google Scholar for papers containing various keywords on Covid-19 and cardiovascular conditions. They also included case studies, retrospective and prospective studies, systematic reviews, meta-analyses and clinical guidelines.

“In writing this article, we hope to increase emergency physicians’ knowledge and awareness of this new pathogen and its impact on the cardiovascular system,” stated Dr William Brady from the University of Virginia’s Health System’s Department of Emergency Medicine.

“As we encounter more and more patients with Covid-19-related illness, we are increasing our understanding of its impact on the body in general and the cardiovascular system in particular. The rate of learning in this area is amazingly rapid. Information continues to change weekly, if not daily,” he stated.

The link between cardiovascular complications and Covid-19

The new paper specifically focused on heart failure in patients with Covid-19. In their research, they noted a previous study reporting that almost a quarter of Covid-19 patients were suffering acute heart failure upon first diagnosis – it should, however, be noted that not all patients with Covid-19 will suffer heart failure.

According to the authors, it remains unclear whether heart complications are a direct cause of Covid-19, or whether Covid-19 simply exacerbates previously undiagnosed heart conditions.

Strokes were also mentioned in the paper – the result of severe inflammation in the body, causing a fatty plaque buildup in the blood vessels, which can be negatively affected by influenza and other viruses.

The authors also mentioned potential interactions with drugs used in Covid-19 patients. The highly-reported hydroxychloroquine could, for example, interact with other medications, originally prescribed to regulate heart rhythm.

The immune response in some Covid-19 patients, where a so-called “cytokine storm” is released in the body, can also affect the heart, as it causes the heart to work harder – similar to the effects of severe influenza and other viral conditions.

It has also been reported that remdesivir, an antiviral which has been emergency-approved by the FDA, can cause low blood pressure and abnormal heart rhythm. According to the authors, it is important that doctors are aware of the interactions these medications may cause.

Brady emphasised that doctors must always keep in mind that the new pathogen causes more than respiratory symptoms, and be constantly aware of new presentations as more discoveries about SARS-CoV-2 are made.

Image credit: Jair Lázaro, Unsplash

Share Button

Coronavirus: ‘Wash hands at least six times a day’

Simple soap and water can kill the virus if you use it often enough, experts say.

Share Button

Coronavirus: Diabetic people offered support

A study reveals, for some, having diabetes is linked to an increased risk of dying with coronavirus.

Share Button

Coronavirus: Cancer surgery delays risk ‘thousands’ of deaths

The NHS is warned not to “lose sight” of other areas of life-saving medicine amid the coronavirus outbreak.

Share Button

Protein shapes matter in Alzheimer’s research

Sometimes proteins misfold. When that happens in the human brain, the pileup of misfolded proteins can lead to neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s and ALS.

Proteins do not misbehave and misfold out of the blue. There is a delicate ecosystem of biochemical interactions and environments that usually let them twist, unfold, refold and do their jobs as they’re meant to.

However, as researchers from Michigan Technological University explore in an article published in ACS Chemical Neuroscience, even a small change may cause long-term consequences.

For amyloid beta peptides — considered a major hallmark of Alzheimer’s disease — a common chemical modification at a particular location on the molecule has a butterfly effect that leads to protein misfolding, aggregation and cellular toxicity.

Ashutosh Tiwari, associate professor of chemistry at Michigan Tech, explains that misfolded amyloid beta proteins tend to pile up and form aggregates, which can form stringy fibrils or balled-up amorphous shapes.

To understand what causes the different shapes and to assess their toxicity, Tiwari’s team looked at acetylation.

Acetylation is one of the most common chemical modifications proteins undergo, but one of the least researched in terms of how it affects amyloid beta toxicity. On amyloid beta proteins, acetylation can occur at two sites: lysine 16 and lysine 28.

The team found that acetylation at lysine 16 led to the disordered aggregates that formed sticky but flexible amorphous structures and showed high levels of toxicity. They also found the aggregates showed higher free radical formation.

“No one has done a systematic study to show if you acetylate amyloid beta it changes how the aggregate looks, then it changes its biophysical properties and hence toxicity,” Tiwari said. “What we’re saying is that the shape, stickiness and flexibility of the aggregated protein structure can play a vital role in the cellular toxicity and may also affect the mechanism of toxicity.”

In Alzheimer’s, these aggregates accumulate in the part of the brain that affects memory. It’s a disease that the Alzheimer’s Organization reports is the sixth leading cause of death in the US and will cost the nation about $305 billion in 2020. Tiwari says what we truly need to understand about the disease is that there is no single cause, no single trigger, and probably no silver bullet because of the chemistry involved.

“This is how a subtle change on a single position can affect a whole protein’s aggregation,” Tiwari said, adding that the effect of acetylation on tau, another protein aggregation, has been far more studied than amyloid beta. Also, many researchers still think a misfolded protein has to look a certain way to become problematic, and that other misfolded forms are less of an issue.

Tiwari agrees some of the proteins’ changes are subtle, and compares discerning the differences and their effects to snow tires. Snow tires have deeper treads and a more flexible material to handle winter roads, but it’s hard to point out those features at highway speeds. Like different kinds of tires, protein shapes can appear indistinguishable at a distance.

“This is not something that can be viewed from afar — it’s a touch-and-feel property,” Tiwari said. “We have to interrogate these properties. We have to look at these structures more deeply from both morphology and biophysical perspectives.”

When we do, we may better understand the complexity of the misfolded proteins and amyloid beta toxicity that can cause neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s.

Share Button

But it’s a dry heat: Climate change and the aridification of North America

Discussions of drought often center on the lack of precipitation. But among climate scientists, the focus is shifting to include the growing role that warming temperatures are playing as potent drivers of greater aridity and drought intensification.

Increasing aridity is already a clear trend across the western United States, where anthropogenic climate warming is contributing to declining river flows, drier soils, widespread tree death, stressed agricultural crops, catastrophic wildfires and protracted droughts, according to the authors of a Commentary article published online May 19 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

At the same time, human-caused warming is also driving increased aridity eastward across North America, with no end in sight, according to climate scientists Jonathan Overpeck of the University of Michigan and Bradley Udall of Colorado State University.

“The impact of warming on the West’s river flows, soils, and forests is now unequivocal,” write Overpeck, dean of the U-M School for Environment and Sustainability, and Udall, senior water and climate scientist at Colorado State. “There is a clear longer-term trend toward greater aridification, a trend that only climate action can stop.”

The Commentary article responds to a PNAS paper, published May 11 by Justin Martin of the U.S. Geological Survey and his colleagues, that showed how warming is causing streamflow declines in the northern Rocky Mountains, including the nation’s largest river basin, the Missouri.

The Martin et al. study used tree-ring records to analyze the 2000-2010 Upper Missouri River Basin drought and concluded that “recent warming aligns with increasing drought severities that rival or exceed any estimated over the last 12 centuries.”

The study details the mechanisms of temperature-driven streamflow declines, and it “places more focus on how anthropogenic climate warming is progressively increasing the risk of hot drought and more arid conditions across an expanding swath of the United States,” according to Overpeck and Udall.

The Martin et al. study also highlights the way temperature-driven aridity in the West is typically framed in terms of episodic drought. Many water and land managers, as well as the general public, implicitly assume that when returning rains and snowfall break a long drought, arid conditions will also fade away.

But that’s a faulty assumption, one that ignores mounting evidence all around us, according to Overpeck and Udall.

“Anthropogenic climate change calls this assumption into question because we now know with high confidence that continued emissions of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere guarantees continued warming, and that this continued warming makes more widespread, prolonged and severe dry spells and droughts almost a sure bet,” they write. “Greater aridity is redefining the West in many ways, and the costs to human and natural systems will only increase as we let the warming continue.”

Anticipated impacts in the Upper Missouri River Basin mirror changes already occurring in the Southwest, where the trend toward warming-driven aridification is clearest.

Rivers in the Southwest provide the only large, sustainable water supply to more than 40 million people, yet flows have declined significantly since the late 20th century. Declining flows in the region’s two most important rivers, the Colorado and the Rio Grande, have been attributed in part to increasing temperatures caused by human activities, most notably the burning of fossil fuels.

Multiple processes tied to warming are likely implicated in the observed aridification of the West, according to Overpeck and Udall. For starters, warmer air can hold more water vapor, and this thirsty air draws moisture from water bodies and land surfaces through evaporation and evapotranspiration — further drying soils, stressing plants and reducing streamflow.

But the atmosphere’s increased capacity to hold water vapor also boosts the potential for precipitation; rain and snow amounts are, in fact, rising in many regions of the United States outside the Southwest. However, the frequency and intensity of dry spells and droughts are expected to increase across much of the continent in coming decades, even if average annual precipitation levels rise, according to Overpeck and Udall.

“Perhaps most troubling is the growing co-occurrence of hot and dry summer conditions, and the likely expansion, absent climate change action, of these hot-dry extremes all the way to the East Coast of North America, north deep into Canada, and south into Mexico,” they write.

“Other parts of North America likely won’t see the widespread aridification and decadal to multi-decadal droughts of the West, but will nonetheless continue to see more frequent and severe arid events — extreme dry spells, flash droughts and interannual droughts will become part of the new normal,” according to Overpeck and Udall.

“Unfortunately, climate change and this aridification are likely irreversible on human time scales, so the sooner emissions of greenhouse gases to the atmosphere are halted, the sooner the aridification of North America will stop getting worse.”

Share Button

NASA’s Curiosity rover finds clues to chilly ancient Mars buried in rocks

By studying the chemical elements on Mars today — including carbon and oxygen — scientists can work backwards to piece together the history of a planet that once had the conditions necessary to support life.

Weaving this story, element by element, from roughly 140 million miles (225 million kilometers) away is a painstaking process. But scientists aren’t the type to be easily deterred. Orbiters and rovers at Mars have confirmed that the planet once had liquid water, thanks to clues that include dry riverbeds, ancient shorelines, and salty surface chemistry. Using NASA’s Curiosity Rover, scientists have found evidence for long-lived lakes. They’ve also dug up organic compounds, or life’s chemical building blocks. The combination of liquid water and organic compounds compels scientists to keep searching Mars for signs of past — or present — life.

Despite the tantalizing evidence found so far, scientists’ understanding of Martian history is still unfolding, with several major questions open for debate. For one, was the ancient Martian atmosphere thick enough to keep the planet warm, and thus wet, for the amount of time necessary to sprout and nurture life? And the organic compounds: are they signs of life — or of chemistry that happens when Martian rocks interact with water and sunlight?

In a recent Nature Astronomy report on a multi-year experiment conducted in the chemistry lab inside Curiosity’s belly, called Sample Analysis at Mars (SAM), a team of scientists offers some insights to help answer these questions. The team found that certain minerals in rocks at Gale Crater may have formed in an ice-covered lake. These minerals may have formed during a cold stage sandwiched between warmer periods, or after Mars lost most of its atmosphere and began to turn permanently cold.

Gale is a crater the size of Connecticut and Rhode Island combined. It was selected as Curiosity’s 2012 landing site because it had signs of past water, including clay minerals that might help trap and preserve ancient organic molecules. Indeed, while exploring the base of a mountain in the center of the crater, called Mount Sharp, Curiosity found a layer of sediments 1,000 feet (304 meters) thick that was deposited as mud in ancient lakes. To form that much sediment an incredible amount of water would have flowed down into those lakes for millions to tens of millions of warm and humid years, some scientists say. But some geological features in the crater also hint at a past that included cold, icy conditions.

“At some point, Mars’ surface environment must have experienced a transition from being warm and humid to being cold and dry, as it is now, but exactly when and how that occurred is still a mystery,” says Heather Franz, a NASA geochemist based at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Maryland.

Franz, who led the SAM study, notes that factors such as changes in Mars’ obliquity and the amount of volcanic activity could have caused the Martian climate to alternate between warm and cold over time. This idea is supported by chemical and mineralogical changes in Martian rocks showing that some layers formed in colder environments and others formed in warmer ones.

In any case, says Franz, the array of data collected by Curiosity so far suggests that the team is seeing evidence for Martian climate change recorded in rocks.

Carbon and oxygen star in the Martian climate story

Franz’s team found evidence for a cold ancient environment after the SAM lab extracted the gases carbon dioxide, or CO2, and oxygen from 13 dust and rock samples. Curiosity collected these samples over the course of five Earth years (Earth years vs. Mars years).

CO2 is a molecule of one carbon atom bonded with two oxygen atoms, with carbon serving as a key witness in the case of the mysterious Martian climate. In fact, this simple yet versatile element is as critical as water in the search for life elsewhere. On Earth, carbon flows continuously through the air, water, and surface in a well-understood cycle that hinges on life. For example, plants absorb carbon from the atmosphere in the form of CO2. In return, they produce oxygen, which humans and most other life forms use for respiration in a process that ends with the release of carbon back into the air, again via CO2, or into the Earth’s crust as life forms die and are buried.

Scientists are finding there’s also a carbon cycle on Mars and they’re working to understand it. With little water or abundant surface life on the Red Planet for at least the past 3 billion years, the carbon cycle is much different than Earth’s.

“Nevertheless, the carbon cycling is still happening and is still important because it’s not only helping reveal information about Mars’ ancient climate,” says Paul Mahaffy, principal investigator on SAM and director of the Solar System Exploration Division at NASA Goddard. “It’s also showing us that Mars is a dynamic planet that’s circulating elements that are the buildings blocks of life as we know it.”

The gases build a case for a chilly period

After Curiosity fed rock and dust samples into SAM, the lab heated each one to nearly 1,650 degrees Fahrenheit (900 degrees Celsius) to liberate the gases inside. By looking at the oven temperatures that released the CO2 and oxygen, scientists could tell what kind of minerals the gases were coming from. This type of information helps them understand how carbon is cycling on Mars.

Various studies have suggested that Mars’ ancient atmosphere, containing mostly CO2, may have been thicker than Earth’s is today. Most of it has been lost to space, but some may be stored in rocks at the planet’s surface, particularly in the form of carbonates, which are minerals made of carbon and oxygen. On Earth, carbonates are produced when CO2 from the air is absorbed in the oceans and other bodies of water and then mineralized into rocks. Scientists think the same process happened on Mars and that it could help explain what happened to some of the Martian atmosphere.

Yet, missions to Mars haven’t found enough carbonates in the surface to support a thick atmosphere.

Nonetheless, the few carbonates that SAM did detect revealed something interesting about the Martian climate through the isotopes of carbon and oxygen stored in them. Isotopes are versions of each element that have different masses. Because different chemical processes, from rock formation to biological activity, use these isotopes in different proportions, the ratios of heavy to light isotopes in a rock provide scientists with clues to how the rock formed.

In some of the carbonates SAM found, scientists noticed that the oxygen isotopes were lighter than those in the Martian atmosphere. This suggests that the carbonates did not form long ago simply from atmospheric CO2 absorbed into a lake. If they had, the oxygen isotopes in the rocks would have been slightly heavier than the ones in the air.

While it’s possible that the carbonates formed very early in Mars’ history, when the atmospheric composition was a bit different than it is today, Franz and her colleagues suggest that the carbonates more likely formed in a freezing lake. In this scenario, the ice could have sucked up heavy oxygen isotopes and left the lightest ones to form carbonates later. Other Curiosity scientists have also presented evidence suggesting that ice-covered lakes could have existed in Gale Crater.

So where is all the carbon?

The low abundance of carbonates on Mars is puzzling, scientists say. If there aren’t many of these minerals at Gale Crater, perhaps the early atmosphere was thinner than predicted. Or maybe something else is storing the missing atmospheric carbon.

Based on their analysis, Franz and her colleagues suggest that some carbon could be sequestered in other minerals, such as oxalates, which store carbon and oxygen in a different structure than carbonates. Their hypothesis is based on the temperatures at which CO2 was released from some samples inside SAM — too low for carbonates, but just right for oxalates — and on the different carbon and oxygen isotope ratios than the scientists saw in the carbonates.

A model of a carbonate molecule next to an oxalate molecule

Oxalates are the most common type of organic mineral produced by plants on Earth. But oxalates also can be produced without biology. One way is through the interaction of atmospheric CO2 with surface minerals, water, and sunlight, in a process known as abiotic photosynthesis. This type of chemistry is hard to find on Earth because there’s abundant life here, but Franz’s team hopes to create abiotic photosynthesis in the lab to figure out if it actually could be responsible for the carbon chemistry they’re seeing in Gale Crater.

On Earth, abiotic photosynthesis may have paved the way for photosynthesis among some of the first microscopic life forms, which is why finding it on other planets interests astrobiologists.

Even if it turns out that abiotic photosynthesis locked some carbon from the atmosphere into rocks at Gale Crater, Franz and her colleagues would like to study soil and dust from different parts of Mars to understand if their results from Gale Crater reflect a global picture. They may one day get a chance to do so. NASA’s Perseverance Mars rover, due to launch to Mars between July and August 2020, plans to pack up samples in Jezero Crater for possible return to labs on Earth.

Share Button