High cost of cancer drugs not always justified

A growing number of new cancer drugs have come on the market in recent years, yet the cost of therapies in Europe and the United States have risen. This is driving up healthcare costs, which poses a challenge not only for the Swiss social insurance system, but for patients all over the world. But are the high prices of cancer drugs justified? Does the cost correspond to the particular drug’s effectiveness in combating the disease? An international research team from the University of Zurich and Harvard Medical School carried out a study to examine these questions.

Cost comparison of 65 cancer drugs

The scientists — led by Kerstin Noëlle Vokinger, professor at UZH — analyzed the costs of cancer drugs in Switzerland, Germany, England, France and the United States. The prices of 65 new oncology drugs to treat solid tumors and various types of blood cancer were adjusted to calculate the monthly treatment costs for a standard patient.

In a second stage, the researchers investigated whether there is a link between monthly treatment costs and the clinical benefit of cancer drugs for solid tumors. The effectiveness of the drugs, which had been approved by the US and European licensing authorities (the FDA and EMA, respectively), was calculated using two well-established systems for evaluating the clinical benefit of cancer therapies: the American Society of Clinical Oncology Value Framework, and the European Society of Medical Oncology Magnitude of Clinical Benefit Scale.

No correlation between cost and benefit

“Our study clearly shows that, in general, for Switzerland, Germany, England and the United States, there is no association between clinical benefit of a cancer drugs and their prices,” explains lead author, Kerstin Vokinger. Only for France a correlation could be found based on one of the clinical benefit assessment systems. “It’s also clear that the prices of cancer drugs in the US are significantly higher than in the four European countries, with Americans paying on average approximately twice as much for the same drug.”

This is because drug pricing in the US is dictated by the free, unregulated market. In Europe, on the other hand, national authorities negotiate prices with manufacturers. From the European countries analyzed in the study, Switzerland has the second-highest prices after England, while the same drugs are cheaper in Germany and France. It must be kept in mind, however, that NHS England benefits from non-public discounts on certain drugs, so the actual prices may be lower than the official list prices.

Drug prices are not justified

“The pricing of cancer drugs is only partially justified. Drugs that are less effective should be cheaper than those with high efficacy,” the UZH professor says. “National authorities should take greater account of the clinical benefits of drugs when negotiating prices, and therapies that provide high clinical benefit should be prioritized in price negotiations.” Vokinger firmly believes that this is crucial in order to guarantee patients access to key cancer drugs since countries have only limited financial resources.

Story Source:

Materials provided by University of Zurich. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Share Button

Coronavirus: What it’s like to be shielding in your twenties

Grace, 26, doesn’t look it but she’s deemed extremely vulnerable – here’s how she’s dealing with having to shield.

Share Button

Conscious Growth Club Q&A and Meet the Members – Video

Today we hosted and recorded a live Q&A call for people who are interested in Conscious Growth Club, so they could ask me questions about it. Several CGC members participated on the call as well, sharing insights on what it’s like inside and answering some extra questions too.

I think this video will give you a better sense of what the vibe is like inside the club, especially the playfulness of how we often interact.

I answer questions about CGC for the first hour, and then we bring some members onto the call to share starting at 1:05:40, so if you want to hear from the members, feel free to skip ahead to that time.

If you’re still on the fence about joining CGC for this year, I’d recommend at least watching the part with the members since that will give you a better sense of how we connect inside the club, which should help you get more clarity about whether you’re a match for CGC.

[embedded content]

Just remember that the deadline for joining CGC this year is the end of the day on May 1st, so please join us by then if you want to be a member of the club this year. Our next opening will be in April 2021.

Several more members joined since we did this call. If history is any indication, there will be a lot more sign-ups on May 1st as well.

Enjoy the video!

Share Button

Children who have difficult relationships with their moms are clingy towards teachers

Children who experience “dependent” or clingy relationships with their preschool teachers tend to also have difficulties in their relationships with their mothers finds researchers at the NYU Steinhardt School of Culture, Education, and Human Development. The research, published in peer-reviewed academic research journal Attachment and Human Behavior, went even further to find that later in elementary school, these children were prone to being anxious, withdrawn, and overly shy.

“Our research suggests that preschool teachers have the potential to play a pivotal role for children who are more dependent,” said Robin Neuhaus, lead researcher and doctoral student in NYU Steinhardt’s Department of Teacher and Learning. “By being warm and supportive, and by encouraging children to explore, preschool teachers may be able to reset the trajectories of children who may otherwise struggle with anxiety in elementary school.”

Analyzing data from 769 children collected by the National Institute of Health’s Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, Neuhaus and her colleagues looked at assessments of mother-child attachment patterns from families across the United States. The sample looked at attachment at 36 months, 54 months, first, third and fifth grades, and examined dependency, closeness, conflict and other behaviors between children and their mothers, as well as children and their teachers.

“Results from multilevel models showed that clingy behavior with preschool teachers was associated with higher levels of anxious behaviors when children were in fifth grade. Clingy behavior also partially mediated the link between a difficult type of mother-child attachment and anxiety in fifth grade,” continued Neuhaus.

Story Source:

Materials provided by New York University. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Share Button

Possibly active tectonic system on the Moon

Researchers have discovered a system of ridges spread across the nearside of the Moon topped with freshly exposed boulders. The ridges could be evidence of active lunar tectonic processes, the researchers say, possibly the echo of a long-ago impact that nearly tore the Moon apart.

“There’s this assumption that the Moon is long dead, but we keep finding that that’s not the case,” said Peter Schultz, a professor in Brown University’s Department of Earth, Environmental and Planetary Sciences and co-author of the research, which is published in the journal Geology. “From this paper it appears that the Moon may still be creaking and cracking — potentially in the present day — and we can see the evidence on these ridges.”

Most of the Moon’s surface is covered by regolith, a powdery blanket of ground-up rock created by the constant bombardment of tiny meteorites and other impactors. Areas free of regolith where the Moon’s bedrock is exposed are vanishingly rare. But Adomas Valantinas, a graduate student at the University of Bern who led the research while a visiting scholar at Brown, used data from NASA’s Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) to spot strange bare spots within and surrounding the lunar maria, the large dark patches on the Moon’s nearside.

“Exposed blocks on the surface have a relatively short lifetime because the regolith buildup is happening constantly,” Schultz said. “So when we see them, there needs to be some explanation for how and why they were exposed in certain locations.”

For the study, Valantinas used the LRO’s Diviner instrument, which measures the temperature of the lunar surface. Just as concrete-covered cities on Earth retain more heat than the countryside, exposed bedrock and blocky surfaces on the Moon stays warmer through the lunar night than regolith-covered surfaces. Using nighttime observations from Diviner, Valantinas turned up more than 500 patches of exposed bedrock on narrow ridges following a pattern across the lunar nearside maria.

A few ridges topped with exposed bedrock had been seen before, Schultz says. But those ridges were on the edges of ancient lava-filled impact basins and could be explained by continued sagging in response to weight caused by the lava fill. But this new study discovered that the most active ridges are related to a mysterious system of tectonic features (ridges and faults) on the lunar nearside, unrelated to both lava-filled basins and other young faults that crisscross the highlands.

“The distribution that we found here begs for a different explanation,” Schultz said.

Valantinas and Schultz mapped out all of the exposures revealed in the Diviner data and found an interesting correlation. In 2014, NASA’s GRAIL mission found a network of ancient cracks in the Moon’s crust. Those cracks became channels through which magma flowed to the Moon’s surface to form deep intrusions. Valantinas and Schultz showed that the blocky ridges seemed to line up just about perfectly with the deep intrusions revealed by GRAIL.

“It’s almost a one-to-one correlation,” Schultz said. “That makes us think that what we’re seeing is an ongoing process driven by things happening in the Moon’s interior.”

Schultz and Valantinas suggest that the ridges above these ancient intrusions arestill heaving upward. The upward movement breaks the surface and enables regolith to drain into cracks and voids, leaving the blocks exposed. Because bare spots on the Moon get covered over fairly quickly, this cracking must be quite recent, possibly even ongoing today. They refer to what they’ve found as ANTS, for Active Nearside Tectonic System.

The researchers believe that the ANTS was actually set in motion billions of years ago with a giant impact on the Moon’s farside. In previous studies, Schultz and a co-worker proposed this impact, which formed the 1500-mile South Pole Aitken Basin, shattered the interior on the opposite side, the nearside facing the Earth. Magma then filled these cracks and controlled the pattern of dikes detected in the GRAIL mission. The blocky ridges comprising the ANTS now trace the continuing adjustments along these ancient weaknesses.

“This looks like the ridges responded to something that happened 4.3 billion years ago,” Schultz said. “Giant impacts have long lasting effects. The Moon has a long memory. What we’re seeing on the surface today is testimony to its long memory and secrets it still holds.”

Story Source:

Materials provided by Brown University. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Share Button

Coronavirus: ‘Probable’ government will miss 100,000 test target

Hospital chiefs say the figure is a “red herring” and the UK must move to mass testing.

Share Button

Coronavirus: NHS sets out six-week plan for ‘return to normal’

Urgent services should return to pre-Covid-19 levels, a letter to local trusts and GPs says.

Share Button

Health24.com | He recovered from Covid-19 – can his blood help others?

Domenico Piccininni is one of the hundreds of thousands of people who have had a Covid-19 infection and recovered after a bit of misery, but with no lasting complications.

What sets him apart from many other survivors is that Piccininni is trying to help people who now have more severe Covid-19 infections.

On Thursday, the Atlanta-area resident donated his plasma. Plasma is a component of blood that contains antibodies, which are made by the immune system in response to a specific infection. Because the 50-year-old Piccininni recovered from a Covid-19 infection, his body now produces antibodies that are primed to fight the new coronavirus.

The hope is that giving his plasma and antibodies (called “convalescent plasma”) will help kick-start the fight against the virus for people who are currently very sick with Covid-19 infections.

‘My wife volunteered me’

Piccininni is a reluctant hero, though. At first, he thought he wouldn’t want anyone to even know that he had been sick with Covid-19. He worried there might be a potential stigma.

“I felt like [having had the infection] might be like a scarlet letter, but the doctor said I should think of it more like a badge of honour, because I could help people,” Piccininni said.

He also admitted to being a bit uneasy about the procedure because he didn’t quite know what to expect.

“My wife volunteered me,” he said, laughing. “I’ve never even donated blood before. But, we have five kids and if one of them were on the edge, I would hope someone would help. As nervous as it might make you feel, you have to think about your fellow humankind. How can you not think about saving a life if you can?”

The good news is that the donation process isn’t a big deal – just a little bit of time and a needlestick.

Dr Kent Holland, medical director of the Blood and Marrow Transplant Program at Northside Hospital (the hospital where Piccininni donated) and Atlanta Blood Services in Atlanta, said, “The donation process is pretty straightforward. The whole process takes about 75 to 90 minutes, and there really aren’t any significant risks.”

Who can donate?

He added that some people may briefly get light-headed and some may have a bruise where the needle went in.

During the donation process, some blood is drawn from you. It’s then run through a special machine that separates the plasma from the rest of the blood. Your blood is then returned to your body, minus the plasma, Holland explained.

Dr Jed Gorlin, medical director of Innovative Blood Resources (a New York Blood Center Enterprise) in St. Paul, Minnesota, said, “Your appointment may be an hour or an hour and a half altogether, but the actual collection time is only about 45 minutes.”

Who can donate? Holland said people who have had a proven Covid-19 infection and have recovered may be eligible to donate. It needs to be at least two weeks since they last had symptoms.

Gorlin said loss of smell is one exception to that symptom rule, however. He said it can take longer than two weeks for the sense of smell to return to normal.

Both experts also said that all the usual rules of blood donation apply, and donors must be considered healthy. People can donate more than once.

Doctors are hopeful

For people receiving the convalescent plasma, it’s like a blood infusion through an IV. Gorlin said it’s only about a cup of fluid, so it’s not a lot of volume. He said the risks to a patient are very low. The most common side effect is a mild allergic reaction.

Theoretically, a reaction might make the inflammatory response of a Covid-19 infection worse, but Gorlin said doctors just don’t know yet if that’s a concern because this hasn’t been well-studied.

Both said convalescent plasma has been used in the past. Holland noted that it was used as far back as the 1918 Spanish flu, and as recently as the SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome) and MERS (Middle East respiratory syndrome) viral infections.

Patients who are in hospitals participating in studies of convalescent plasma can access the treatment. If a patient is in a hospital that isn’t conducting a study, doctors can apply for what’s called an “Emergency IND” – that’s individual expanded access for emergency use – from the US Food and Drug Administration.

Gorlin noted that physicians can also request convalescent plasma through the Mayo Clinic extended access programme.

Holland said that while doctors are hopeful the convalescent plasma will help patients recover faster, “It’s too early to know yet. It’s a relatively safe therapy, but I would caution people that while it looks promising, all the evidence right now is anecdotal.”

READ | Could tiny blood clots make Covid-19 more lethal?

READ | Could coronavirus survivors’ blood help save very ill patients?

READ | More evidence that coronavirus survivors’ blood could help very ill patients

Image credit: iStock

Share Button

Coronavirus: PM to update UK on ‘steps to defeat’ coronavirus

Boris Johnson will lead the Downing Street briefing later for the first time since his return to work.

Share Button

Health24.com | Coronavirus morning update: U-turn on cigarette sales – and more on lockdown level 4

WHAT’S HAPPENING IN SA

Cases update: 

The latest number of confirmed cases is 5 350.

According to the latest update, 103 deaths have been recorded in the country.

So far, 197 127 tests have been conducted, with more than 11 600 new tests.

The Western Cape is an area of concern, as highlighted in a release from Health Minister Zweli Mkhize:

“The number of new cases in WC has almost doubled from 133 the day before to 264 today. This was also the highest number of new cases in this province in any 24 hour cycle.

“Also of note is that this province has the highest positivity yield from their tests in the past 24 hours at 7.5% when compared to other provinces.

“In the past 24 hours the Western Cape contributed to 75% of the total new cases nationally while only contributing 30% of total tests over the same period.”

READ MORE |All the confirmed cases of coronavirus in SA

Latest news:

SEE | Here is a list of what you can and not do under level 4 lockdown

Come Friday, cigarettes will still not be allowed to be sold at level four of lockdown.

The u-turn comes after government received over 2 000 submissions from the public opposing the sale of tobacco products, Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs Nkosazna Dlamini-Zuma said.

The minister was speaking at a briefing on Wednesday evening on the new regulations for industries which will restart their operations as the country gradually starts resuming economic activity.

Last week President Cyril Ramaphosa announced that the restrictions on economic activity would be lifted in a gradual risk-adjusted process, based on five coronavirus levels. The country is currently at level five which only allows essential services to operate. More businesses however will be able to operate from Friday, when we move to level four.

Initially government had proposed that the sale of cigarettes would be allowed at level four, but government had received submissions from the public opposing it on the grounds that it posed a health risk, Dlamini-Zuma said. “Besides the effects of tobacco on lungs and the way tobacco is shared, it does not allow for social distancing and encourages the spread of the virus.”

The minister specifically raised an example made in one submission, where concerns were raised about spreading the virus in saliva, when one has to lick paper when rolling a “zol”.

READ MORE | Lockdown: Cigarettes, liquor still won’t be for sale on Level 4

South Africans can run, cycle and walk from Friday but only within a 5km radius from their homes between 06:00 and 09:00.

This was announced on Wednesday evening by Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs Minister Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma.

She said more than 22 000 South Africans had submitted pleas to exercise during the government’s public participation period.

President Cyril Ramaphosa previously promised some respite for his cooped-up countrymen, but “under very strict conditions”, Dlamini-Zuma reminded the nation.

READ MORE | Level 4 lockdown: You can now run, cycle, walk but only under strict conditions

Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, said government will allow the energy and refineries sector to return to operation under the terms of level 4 of the national lockdown.

Dlamini-Zuma was speaking on Wednesday evening and unpacked which industries would be allowed to operate under level 4 of the coronavirus lockdown which will come into effect on Friday, when lockdown deescalates from level 5.

According to the South African Petroleum Industry Association, the local sector supplies to 200 depots, 4600 service stations and 100 000 consumers nationally.

Last week President Cyril Ramaphosa announced a five-level system would be put in place from 1 May to allow the economy to return to function in phases.

Coal miners supplying Eskom were allowed to continue operating during lockdown and mining companies have been granted permission to return to work on a case-by-case basis in recent weeks.

Dlamini-Zuma said bringing refineries back to operation under level 4 was a critical part of getting the economy ticking again.

READ MORE | Lockdown: Refineries to return to operation under level 4

E-commerce may be expanded incrementally during lockdown level 4, now referred to as Alert Level 4 in government documents, to include items currently excluded, trade and industry minister Ebrahim Patel said on Thursday night. 

South Africa is due to embark on a phased reopening of the economy on Friday, starting with lockdown level 4, which will see several industries returning to work, and the purchase of additional items allowed. 

Patel said online retailers will be allowed to sell essential food items, winter clothing, bedding, hot foods, stationery and cellphones during lockdown level 4 – but that could change.

“E-commerce will be expanded incrementally as an immediate step,” Patel said during a press conference on the differences between hard lockdown and level 4. “Deliveries of a larger list of products will be possible and it will be expanded further in level 4”

But regulations from the department of cooperative governance and traditional, due to be gazetted on Thursday, say that before e-commere is expanded, how to limit movement on roads will be considered. 

READ MORE | New regulations hint online retailers may get to sell more stuff under level 4 – eventually

In a media briefing on Wednesday evening, Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma confirmed that despite public calls for hairdressers and nail salons to re-open, this will not be happening in Level 4 of lockdown.

The danger of contracting Covid-19 is too high with these services, given that there is “no social distancing”, Dlamini Zuma said.

According to government’s current risk adjusted strategy, hairdressers and beauty salons may only open when South Africa reaches Level 1. 

“People are touching,” she said, adding that it was “too risky”.

But she said that products that will allow people to treat their own hair, and do pedicures and hand manicures at home, have been added to the list of goods that may be sold in Level 4. 

READ MORE | Hairdressers, salons stay shut – but you can buy products to do manicures at home from Friday

President Cyril Ramaphosa is still considering the release of 19 000 prisoners amid the coronavirus pandemic.

So says Deputy Justice Minister Patekile Holomisa who was addressing a virtual meeting of the Portfolio Committee on Justice and Correctional Services and Select Committee on Security and Justice on Wednesday.

MPs had asked him about the release of the prisoners, which was mooted earlier.

“That is a matter that is still being considered by the president,” Holomisa said, adding the department had presented its plan to Ramaphosa.

“So, we are not in a position to pronounce on what the details are.”

Earlier, Justice Minister Ronald Lamola told the committees physical distancing was not practical at correctional centres.

READ MORE | President still considering release of 19 000 inmates amid Covid-19 outbreak

WHAT’S HAPPENING IN THE REST OF THE WORLD 

Cases update:

For the latest global data, follow this interactive map from Johns Hopkins University & Medicine.

Late on Wednesday night, positive cases worldwide were close to 3.18 million, while deaths were more than 226 000.

The United States had the most cases in the world – close to 1  035 000, as well as the most deaths – more than 60 000.

READ MORE | All the confirmed cases worldwide

Latest news:

Gilead Science’s remdesivir, one of the most highly anticipated drugs being tested against the new coronavirus, showed positive results in a large-scale US government trial, the company said Wednesday.

Remdesivir is an anti-viral drug.

“We understand that the trial has met its primary endpoint and that National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (Niaid) will provide detailed information at an upcoming briefing,” the company said.

Though it is difficult to precisely quantify the finding in the absence of results, it represents the first time any drug has been shown to improve outcomes against the Covid-19 illness, which has claimed more than 200 000 lives globally and brought the world economy to a grinding halt.

READ MORE | Covid-19 remdesivir drug trials: manufacturer says its working, but a study finds ‘no benefits’

The Swedish university town of Lund will spread foul smelling chicken fertiliser in its main park this week to deter revellers holding spring celebrations as part of efforts to curb the coronavirus outbreak, officials said on Wednesday.

City officials have asked residents to skip the traditional Walpurgis Eve celebrations on 30 April, known in Sweden as Valborg, and plan to fence off the Lund city park.

But they told AFP they would also go a step further and take the opportunity to spread one ton of chicken droppings in the park.

While giving the lawns a welcome dose of nutrition, they also hope it will keep at bay those who would otherwise be tempted to defy the coronavirus restrictions.

“Well, chicken manure simply smells awful,” Gustav Lundblad, chairman of the city’s environment board, told AFP.

“It’s not very pleasant to sit around drinking beer in that smell,” Lundblad added.

The park is a popular gathering spot for afternoon and early evening picnics on 30 April, before the traditional bonfires later in the evening.

Since the festivities – which can attract up to 30 000 visitors – are “spontaneous”, the city cannot outright ban them but given the coronavirus outbreak, Lundblad said the city strongly wanted to avoid them.

READ MORE | Swedish town to use ‘stinky’ fertiliser to deter spring revellers

LATEST RESEARCH

As the list for possible treatments for the new coronavirus grows, a new ingredient, famotidine, has joined the ranks.

This is the active ingredient found in common over-the-counter heartburn remedies.

Testing this compound against the novel coronavirus began, when on 7 April 2020, Covid-19 patients at Northwell Health in the New York City area began receiving famotidine intravenously, according to reports.

The dose given to these patients is nine times higher than the dose needed to treat heartburn. The hospital kept quiet about the test to prevent people from stockpiling this common drug before it was even proven to work

READ MORE | Heartburn remedy in clinical trial for coronavirus

As the world continues to fight the coronavirus pandemic, with over 2.3 million reported cases at the time of publishing this article, many countries are seeing a rise in cases – South Africa included.

As of 28 April, the country has a total number of 4 793 confirmed cases, and 87 confirmed deaths. And, according to News24, Africa, and by extension South Africa, is not currently on the top of supply lists for life-saving ventilators.

However, a multidisciplinary team of engineers and healthcare practitioners at the University of Johannesburg (UJ), led by UJ’s Dr Deon Sabatta and Dr Samson Masebinu, aim to create open-source, cheap ventilators, a media release explained.

Government projections indicate that the virus could peak in South Africa in September 2020. If the lockdown hadn’t happened, the peak rate would have been expected in July. Currently, 27 Covid-19 patients are on ventilator support in hospitals, which is seemingly in line with government’s projections, reports News24.

READ MORE | Amid SA’s looming shortage, UJ creates open-source, cheap ventilators

Last week Health24 reported on the latest coronavirus vaccine development in Germany – the fourth candidate to go to the clinical trial phase.

Now, a vaccine candidate from the Jenner Institute at the Oxford University, UK, was able to leap ahead as they have had previous trials with similar types of injections, according to reports.

According to information from the Jenner Institute, a chimpanzee adenovirus vaccine vector was chosen as the most suitable vaccine type for the new coronavirus, as it can create a strong immune response from only one dose.

This new development is called ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 and will be produced on a mass-scale.

READ MORE | Oxford University moves forward in coronavirus vaccine race

While there is no vaccine to protect against the new coronavirus, scientists and medical experts are buying time by looking at the effects of existing drugs.

Lopinavir-ritonavir (LPV/r) is a combination of antivirals used to treat HIV.

The possibility of using this drug combination to treat Covid-19 started when the World Health Organization (WHO) announced their Solidarity trial – a collaboration between different countries, where four existing drugs would be trialled to determine their effect on Covid-19 patients.

One of these drugs is the lopinavir-ritonavir combination. While there was no certainty that it would be effective in Covid-19 patients, there were some positive indications from laboratory experiments, according to the WHO.

READ MORE | Lopinavir-ritonavir not effective against Covid-19, says Department of Health

HEALTH TIPS (as recommended by the NICD and WHO)

• Maintain physical distancing – stay at least one metre away from somebody who is coughing or sneezing

• Practise frequent hand-washing, especially after direct contact with ill people or their environment

• Avoid touching your eyes, nose and mouth, as your hands touch many surfaces and could potentially transfer the virus

• Practise respiratory hygiene – cover your mouth with your bent elbow or tissue when you cough or sneeze. Remember to dispose the tissue immediately after use.

READ MORE: Coronavirus 101 

Image credit: Getty Images

Share Button