Health24.com | Not all psychopaths are criminals – some turn out to be ‘successful’ instead

  • Many psychopaths refrain from antisocial or criminal acts
  • To understand why, researchers at Virginia Commonwealth University carried out a study
  • Their results revealed a key difference between ‘successful’ and ‘unsuccessful’ psychopaths

Psychopaths can be alarmingly violent, but, contrary to popular belief, this may only apply to the minority. Instead, many people with the personality disorder refrain from criminal or antisocial acts, and may even go on to become successful in the working field.

A team of researchers from Virginia Commonwealth University in the US wanted to understand what leads to this success. Through their research, they discovered what leads to the formation of this “successful” phenotype. 

Psychopaths in the world

It’s unclear exactly how many psychopaths exist in the world today. Research published in the American Psychological Association journal indicates that, for reasons poorly understood, males demonstrate higher levels of psychopathic traits than females, while the Atlantic reports that psychopaths make up around 1% of the US population.

According to a previous Health24 article, a psychopath is, as defined by internationally renowned psychopathy researcher Robert Hare: “A social predator who often charms and manipulates his or her way through life. Psychopaths are completely lacking in conscience and feelings for others; they take what they want and do as they please without the slightest sense of guilt or regret.”

If you’re wondering what makes a psychopath, it may be a “mixture of nature and nurture” in that it could be in one’s DNA, or that one’s upbringing could have an impact on whether you become a psychopath, Business Insider reported. 

Why the common perception of psychopaths as violent?

There is truth to the notion that psychopathic individuals are more likely than others to commit crimes. However, this does not mean that all psychopaths are criminals.

According to an article published by The Conversation and written by Scott Lilienfeld, a professor of psychology and Ashley Watts, this misconception is largely due to researchers who have tended to seek out psychopaths where they can locate them in large numbers, i.e. prisons. This means that much of the research is focused on “unsuccessful” psychopaths.

In fact, Health24 published an article on the topic last year, noting that there’s a growing realisation that many psychopaths thrive in the workplace. 

Ability to ‘inhibit’ impulses

Researchers of the study, which will be published in a forthcoming issue of the journal Personality Disorders: Theory, Research, and Treatment, separated psychotic individuals into two groups: “successful” vs. “unsuccessful”. This was based on their life trajectories (the path in life one chooses) and outcomes. 

The successful psychopath, for instance, is a CEO or lawyer, whereas an unsuccessful psychopath, who may possess the same traits, is someone who has been convicted of a crime.

Researchers incorporated a compensatory model of “successful” psychopathy into their study. This model theorises that relatively successful psychopaths develop greater conscientious traits, which ultimately leads to an inhibition of heightened antisocial impulses. 

“The compensatory model posits that people higher in certain psychopathic traits (such as grandiosity and manipulation) are able to compensate for and overcome, to some extent, their antisocial impulses via increases in trait conscientiousness, specifically impulse control,” said lead author Emily Lasko, a doctoral candidate in the Department of Psychology in the College of Humanities and Sciences.

Control and aggression

Data from around 1 354 serious juvenile offenders in Arizona and Pennsylvania in the US were collected, and the research team used this to test the model. Among the offenders who re-offended less, termed as the “successful” offenders by the researchers, an especially magnified link between steep increases in general inhibitory control, as well as the inhibition of aggression over time was observed. 

“Psychopathic individuals are very prone to engaging in antisocial behaviours, but what our findings suggest is that some may actually be better able to inhibit these impulses than others,” Lasko said, adding: “Although we don’t know exactly what precipitates this increase in conscientious impulse control over time, we do know that this does occur for individuals high in certain psychopathy traits who have been relatively more ‘successful’ than their peers.”

How the study’s findings may help

The researchers’ results, therefore, support the compensatory model of “successful” psychopathy and run contradictory to other existing psychopathy models, Lasko explained: “Our findings… focus more on the strengths or ‘surpluses’ associated with psychopathy rather than just deficits. Psychopathy is not a personality trait simply composed of deficits – there are many forms that it can take.”

Lasko further explained that the team hopes these findings could be useful within clinical and forensic settings, especially in developing effective and early intervention strategies that could potentially identify the strengths of psychopathic individuals, and ultimately deter any future antisocial behaviour.

NEXT ON HEALTH24X

Share Button

Ancient bird figurine recovered from refuse heap the oldest instance of East Asian 3D art

A small bird carving — the oldest instance of East Asian three-dimensional art ever discovered — is described in a study published June 10, 2020 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Zhanyang Li from Shandong University, China, and colleagues.

European animal and human mammoth ivory carvings dated to 40-38 ka are our earliest examples of prehistoric humans three-dimensionally representing the world around them — though due to a lack of evidence, it’s unclear when this type of three-dimensional representation became part of the cultural repertoire of prehistoric groups around the rest of the world. In this study, Li and colleagues describe the remarkable discovery of a small standing bird carving from the Paleolithic site of Lingjing, in Henan, China, that sheds further light on humanity’s earliest three-dimensional art.

During Li’s initial excavation at Lingjing in 2005, he uncovered eleven distinct stratified layers ranging in age from 120,000 years ago to the Bronze Age — and found that most of the fifth layer had been removed during a well-digging operation in 1958. However, the refuse heap from the well’s creation was still intact and remained nearby. After sifting through the sediment in the refuse heap, the authors discovered black flint identical to (and only found in) what remained of Layer 5 at the dig site. They also uncovered several artifacts, including pottery sherds, burned animal remains, and the bird figurine, which is carved from bone and shaped like a songbird on a pedestal.

Using radiocarbon dating on the uncovered burned animal remains (including one bone with anthropogenic gouging marks also observed on the bird carving), the authors were able to estimate the age of the bird figurine and associated bone material to be approximately 13.4-13.2 ka cal BP. Based on evidence from other Northern Chinese sites of similar age, this suggests that hunter-gatherers with stone tool technologies occupied Lingjing and created the bird carving during this time.

Bird representations are a theme in Chinese Neolithic art, with the oldest example a jade songbird dated to approximately 5 ka BP. This Paleolithic bone bird figurine from Lingjing predates previously known instances from this region by almost 8,500 years, and has several technological and stylistic elements distinguishing it from contemporaneous representations of birdlike creatures from Western Europe and Siberia (such as the pedestal on which the Lingjing bird is perched). Though more examples of Paleolithic carving art are needed to confirm this possibility, the Lingjing bird figurine suggests the presence of a longstanding artistic tradition specific to East Asia, with origins much earlier in the Paleolithic.

The authors add: “This discovery identifies an original artistic tradition and pushes back by more than 8,500 years the representation of birds in Chinese art. The figurine differs technologically and stylistically from other specimens found in Western Europe and Siberia, and it could be the missing link tracing the origin of Chinese statuary back to the Palaeolithic period.”

Story Source:

Materials provided by PLOS. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Share Button

Coronavirus: ‘Earlier lockdown would have halved death toll’

Former government adviser Prof Neil Ferguson was giving evidence to a committee of MPs.

Share Button

Proposed seismic surveys in Arctic Refuge likely to cause lasting damage

Winter vehicle travel can cause long-lasting damage to the tundra, according to a new paper by University of Alaska Fairbanks researchers published in the journal Ecological Applications.

Scars from seismic surveys for oil and gas exploration in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge remained for decades, according to the study. The findings counter assertions made by the Bureau of Land Management in 2018 that seismic exploration causes no “significant impacts” on the landscape. That BLM determination would allow a less-stringent environmental review process of seismic exploration in the Arctic Refuge 1002 Area.

UAF’s Martha Raynolds, the lead author of the study, said she and other scientists have documented lasting impacts of winter trails throughout years of field research. Their paper, authored by an interdisciplinary team with expertise in Arctic vegetation, snow, hydrology and permafrost, summarizes what is currently known about the effects of Arctic seismic exploration and what additional information is needed to effectively regulate winter travel to minimize impacts.

A grid pattern of seismic survey lines is used to study underground geology. These trails, as well as trails caused by camps that support workers, damage the underlying tundra, even when limited to frozen, snow-covered conditions. Some of the existing scars on the tundra date back more than three decades, when winter 2D seismic surveys were initiated. Modern 3D surveying requires a tighter network of survey lines, with larger crews and more vehicles. The proposed 1002 Area survey would result in over 39,000 miles of tracks.

“Winter tundra travel is not a technology that has changed much since the ’80s,” said Raynolds, who studies Arctic vegetation at UAF’s Institute of Arctic Biology. “The impacts are going to be as bad or worse, and there are proposing many, many more miles of trails.”

Conditions for winter tundra travel have become more difficult, due to a mean annual temperature increase of 7-9 degrees F on Alaska’s Arctic coastal plain since 1986. Those warmer conditions have contributed to changing snow cover and thawing permafrost. The impact of tracks on the vegetation, soils and permafrost eventually changes the hydrology and habitat of the tundra, which affects people and wildlife who rely on the ecosystem.

The paper argues that more data are needed before proceeding with Arctic Refuge exploration efforts. That includes better information about the impacts of 3D seismic exploration; better weather records in the region, particularly wind and snow data; and high-resolution maps of the area’s ground ice and hydrology. The study also emphasizes that the varied terrain and topography in the 1002 Area are different from other parts of the North Slope, making it more vulnerable to damage from seismic exploration.

Other contributors to the paper included UAF’s Mikhail Kanevskiy, Matthew Sturm and Donald “Skip” Walker; Anna Liljedahl, UAF and Woods Hole Research Center; Janet Jorgenson, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service; Torre Jorgenson, Alaska Ecoscience; and Matthew Nolan, Fairbanks Fodar.

Story Source:

Materials provided by University of Alaska Fairbanks. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Share Button

Physics principle explains order and disorder of swarms

Current experiments support the controversial hypothesis that a well-known concept in physics — a “critical point” — is behind the striking behaviour of collective animal systems. Physicists from the Cluster of Excellence “Centre for the Advanced Study of Collective Behaviour” at the University of Konstanz showed that light-controlled microswimming particles can be made to organize into different collective states such as swarms and swirls. By studying the particles fluctuating between these states, they provide evidence for critical behaviour — and support for a physical principle underlying the complex behaviour of collectives. The research results were published in the scientific journal Nature Communications.

Animal groups exhibit the seemingly contradictory characteristics of being both robust and flexible. Imagine a school of fish: hundreds of individuals in perfect order and alignment can suddenly transition to a convulsing tornado dodging an attack. Animal groups benefit if they can strike this delicate balance between being stable in the face of “noise” like eddies or gusts of wind, yet responsive to important changes like the approach of a predator.

Critical transition

How they achieve this is not yet understood. But in recent years, a possible explanation has emerged: criticality. In physics, criticality describes systems in which a transition between states — such as gas to liquid — occurs at a critical point. Criticality has been argued to provide biological systems with the necessary balance between robustness and flexibility. “The combination of stability and high responsiveness is exactly what characterizes a critical point,” says the study’s lead author Clemens Bechinger, Principal Investigator in the Centre for the Advanced Study of Collective Behaviour and Professor in the Department of Physics at the University of Konstanz, “and so it made sense to test if this could explain some of the patterns we see in collective behaviour.”

The hypothesis that collective states are hovering near critical points has been studied in the past largely through numerical simulations. In the new study published in Nature Communications, Bechinger and his colleagues have given rare experimental support to the mathematical prediction. “By demonstrating a close link between collectivity and critical behaviour, our findings not only add to our general understanding of collective states but also suggest that general physical concepts may apply to living systems,” says Bechinger.

Experimental evidence

In experiments, the researchers used glass beads coated on one side by a carbon cap and placed in a viscous liquid. When illuminated by light, they swim much like bacteria, but with an important difference: every aspect of how the particles interact with others — from how the individuals move to how many neighbours can be seen — can be controlled. These microswimming particles allow the researchers to eschew the challenges of working with living systems in which rules of interaction cannot be easily controlled. “We design the rules in the computer, put them in an experiment, and watch the result of the interaction game,” says Bechinger.

But to ensure that the physical system bore a resemblance to living systems, the researchers designed interactions that mirrored the behaviour of animals. For example, they controlled the direction that individuals moved in relation to their neighbours: particles were programmed either to swim straight towards others in the main group or to deviate away from them. Depending on this angle of movement, the particles organized into either swirls or disordered swarms. And incrementally adjusting this value elicited rapid transitions between a swirl and a disordered but still cohesive swarm. “What we observed is that the system can make sudden transitions from one state to the other, which demonstrates the flexibility needed to react to an external perturbation like a predator,” says Bechinger, “and provides clear evidence for a critical behaviour.”

“Similar behaviour to animal groups and neural systems”

This result is “key to understanding how animal collectives have evolved,” says Professor Iain Couzin, co-speaker of the Centre for the Advanced Study of Collective Behaviour and Director of the Department of Collective Behavior at the Konstanz Max Planck Institute of Animal Behavior. Although not involved with the study, Couzin has worked for decades to decipher how grouping may enhance sensing capabilities in animal collectives.

Says Couzin: “The particles in this study behave in a very similar way to what we see in animal groups, and even neural systems. We know that individuals in collectives benefit from being more responsive, but the big challenge in biology has been testing if criticality is what allows the individual to spontaneously become much more sensitive to their environment. This study has confirmed this can occur just via spontaneous emergent physical properties. Through very simple interactions they have shown that you can tune a physical system to a collective state — criticality — of balance between order and disorder.”

Application areas

By demonstrating the existence of a link between collectivity and critical behaviour in living systems, this study also hints at how the intelligence of collectives can be engineered into physical systems. Beyond just simple particles, the finding could assist with designing efficient strategies of autonomous microrobotics devices with on-board control units. “Similar to their living counterparts, these miniature agents should be able to spontaneously adapt to changing conditions and even cope with unforeseen situations which might be accomplished by their operation near a critical point,” says Bechinger.

Key facts:

  • Physicists from the University of Konstanz show a link between collective behaviour and a concept in physics known as criticality.
  • Through experiments using tiny glass particles, they create collective states of swarms and swirls.
  • Showing that the particles can make sudden transitions from one state to the other provides clear evidence for a critical behaviour
  • Original publication: Bäuerle, T., Löffler, R.C. & Bechinger, C. Formation of stable and responsive collective states in suspensions of active colloids. Nat Commun 11, 2547 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-16161-4
  • Authors include Tobias Bäuerle (lead author) and Robert Löffler, both doctoral students at the University of Konstanz. Senior author Clemens Bechinger is Professor of Physics at the University of Konstanz
  • Clemens Bechinger is also part of the University of Konstanz’s Cluster of Excellence “Centre for the Advanced Study of Collective Behaviour,” which has been funded in the Excellence Strategy of the German Federal and State Governments since 2019.
  • The research was supported by an ERC Advanced Grant ASCIR and the Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) under Germany’s Excellence Strategy — EXC 2117 — 42203798.
  • campus.kn is the University of Konstanz’s online magazine. We use multimedia approaches to provide insights into our research and science, study and teaching as well as life on campus.

Story Source:

Materials provided by University of Konstanz. Original written by Carla Avolio. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Share Button

Vegas and the Virus

On Sunday Rachelle and I went for an early morning walk along the Vegas Strip, mostly outside. I wanted to go mainly for curiosity’s sake. Normally the Strip is very uncrowded in the morning and then gets busier as lunchtime approaches, so I wasn’t expecting much activity till 10am or so. I figured the risk would be relatively low relative to what I might learn and share.

Some casinos are still open while others are still shuttered. What we saw, however, were varying degrees of safety measures – definitely inconsistent among different properties.

Every place had abundant hand sanitizer stations and limited seating at slots and table games (like only 3 chairs per blackjack table), so that at least enforces some social distancing.

Casino employees wore masks everywhere, including the dealers.

A few places had plexiglass dividers around the tables, providing some separation between dealers and patrons. Other places had no dividers at all.

A few places had free mask dispensers. Most open places didn’t seem to have these, however.

At first the area seemed like a ghost town. When we started our walk, it was the most deserted I’d even seen the Strip, even at this time of day. On some stretches it seemed like we were the only two people on the whole block. Occasionally I wondered if we were in a zombie apocalypse movie.

For the most part, it was relatively easy to practice social distancing at this time of day, but we also saw plenty that concerned us, especially as more people woke up and crowds started to form in some places.

First, wearing masks inside the casinos is optional for guests. While we saw many people wearing masks, a lot were mask-free. While masks don’t provide perfect protection, they do provide some, and seeing maskless people walking around inside the casinos gave me the impression that some people don’t care as much.

The most concerning sign though is that many people clearly aren’t practicing social distancing, and the casinos aren’t enforcing that within their walls. It looks like they’re playing lip service to social distancing with the chairs and many signs spelling out safety rules, but it’s clear that plenty of guests aren’t following even the most basic rules.

The places we saw that looked the most unsafe to me were the Venetian and the Flamingo. They were the most crowded places during our walk, and I saw a real lack of social distancing inside. I wouldn’t feel safe hanging out in those casinos.

Crowds of people were bunching up in various places, and in some areas that get a lot of traffic, proper social distancing isn’t realistically possible.

The casinos have clearly made changes, but when I looked with my own eyes, I got the distinct impression that a lot of it was more for show than substance. If mask-free people are going to bunch up a lot in high traffic areas, including standing in clusters behind the table games, I don’t see the Strip as being a safe place for visitors while the virus is still around.

I’m glad we went early in the day when it wasn’t crowded (relatively speaking), and we could spot problem areas and avoid them. But based on what I saw, it’s no stretch to expect that these problems will surely be worse later in the day, especially in the evenings. If we’re seeing issues in the early morning hours, they’re only going to amplify as the day goes on.

Normally the Strip has a certain kind of playful, excited, and fun vibe that I’m very familiar with. The vibe this time felt different – more somber and less fun. The feeling inside the casinos felt almost desperate to me.

When we first started walking, it was eerily quiet and looked abandoned. There was a lot of trash on the sidewalks in front of places that hadn’t yet reopened, like Planet Hollywood. At one point Rachelle spotted what looked like a glass of urine… at another point a condom on the ground – and those were inside open casinos. At least the condom was still in the wrapper. Normally the Strip has high standards of cleanliness, so it may be that they’re having some issues ramping back up to previous standards. That doesn’t bode well if they’re trying to raise their standards during this time though.

Unfortunately I think the tourists who are starting to come back to Vegas right now include too many ignorant and reckless folks. I’d recommend against visiting Vegas for tourism during this time. Remember that it’s not just about your own health but about the lives of others you could infect. I don’t intend to go back there anytime soon.

I contrast this experience with another recent morning walk we took yesterday in our neighborhood, through a long winding trail in a park. Locally we saw lots of good social distancing, including people going out of their way and walking on the grass to avoid others. But in the tourist areas, it was mostly the opposite.

Share Button

Health24.com | Covid-19 exacts emotional toll on doctors

  • Healthcare workers worldwide are experiencing increasing levels of stress and depression
  • Medical personnel need to be looked after, as thousands of people depend on them
  • In addition, healthcare workers face a greater risk of infection than the rest of the population 

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

In a possible harbinger of future mental health problems among doctors working during the coronavirus pandemic, new research shows how the levels of depression, anxiety and fear jumped among young doctors in China treating Covid-19 patients.

Chinese and American researchers found that for more than 380 medical residents in Shanghai, their mental woes were greater than among last year’s first-year residents.

“Even before this pandemic, the levels of depression and anxiety symptoms among our healthcare workers were high, and our findings indicate that they are getting worse,” said researcher Dr Srijan Sen, a University of Michigan psychiatrist and neuroscientist.

“As it is clear that this pandemic will be with us for the foreseeable future, we need to prioritise the well-being of our healthcare workers, not only for themselves, but also for the patients that will need them in the coming months and year,” Sen said in a university news release.

Growing public health crisis

Researcher Dr Weidong Li, a professor at the Shanghai Jiao Tong University, said that late winter is a time of heightened emotions in China, due to the Lunar New Year.

“Our findings indicate that the negative mental health effects of Covid-19 are not limited to physicians working at the centre of the initial outbreak in Wuhan, but extend to other places like Shanghai, which is 500 miles away,” he said.

“With the numerous new cases spread worldwide, this has important implications for the way communities around the globe respond to this growing public health crisis,” Li added.

This year’s class of residents saw changes in most measures of mental health and workplace violence, the researchers found. Other research has shown that first-year medical training is tied to increases in depressive symptoms, the researchers noted.

“It’s easy to forget that they face many of the same additional stresses as the rest of us – concerns about elderly or at-risk family, loss of childcare – while simultaneously managing an increased clinical workload, and all while placing themselves and their families at greater risk of infection,” said researcher Elena Frank, director of the Intern Health Study and a member of Sen’s lab at Michigan.

“The potential mental health consequences of confronting such enormous pressures cannot be overlooked,” Frank said in the release.

The report was published online on 1 June in the journal JAMA Network Open.

Image credit: iStock

Share Button

Health24.com | How far does a virus spread in 10 hours in a hospital ward?

  • A harmless, fake virus was introduced into a paediatric ward at a London hospital to assess how far its DNA can spread
  • In 10 hours it had spread to 41% of all surfaces in the ward
  • It proved a need for intensified cleaning procedures to help curb the spread of Covid-19

How fast does a virus really spread in a hospital? One simulation recently showed that it can take only 10 hours for a virus to contaminate 41% of all surfaces in a single hospital ward. 

Published as a letter in the Journal of Hospital Infection by University College London and Great Ormond Street Hospital, researchers smeared a harmless DNA oligonucleotide surrogate on a bed rail in a paediatric ward’s isolation room. The “fake virus” could also be easily destroyed by proper handwashing regiments and alcohol wipes, thus simulating the prevention of the Covid-19 virus.

The surrogate was put in place on a Monday morning, and 44 samples were taken from surfaces in the evening, then every evening for the next four days. The surfaces included the immediate vicinity of the infection area, clinical areas outside of the isolation room and the general ward. 

READ: Loss of smell, taste – researchers think these symptoms may help better screen for Covid-19

In the first 10 hours, 41% of all surfaces sampled were ‘infected’ with the surrogate, reaching its peak at 52% on day three. According to the letter, this meant that cleaning procedures were not adequate, and that patient and healthcare worker movements need to be better monitored.

In South Africa, many hospitals have seen outbreaks of Covid-19. The Netcare St Augustine’s Hospital in Durban saw an outbreak that infected 135 patients and staff – all caused by one patient that tested positive for Covid-19. According to a study by the University of KwaZulu-Natal, researchers argue that the movement of patients between wards contributed to the outbreak. 

The virus does not remain airborne, thus they conclude that droplets on surfaces contributed to the spread. Early detection and isolation of Covid-19-positive patients were also delayed too long. They recommend more intensive cleaning procedures, as well as creating “zones” that demarcate confirmed and suspected cases away from uninfected patients.

READ: Mental health effects of Covid-19 pandemic, lockdown – and concern over suicide risk

handwashing infographic

Image credit: Pixabay

Share Button

Health24.com | Should I be following a ketogenic diet? A dietitian weighs in

  • The ketogenic diet is a popular diet that focuses on large amounts of fat.
  • Possible health benefits have been discussed at length.
  • While there are great success stories, this diet is not suitable for everyone.

The ketogenic diet has recently become one of the most popular fad diets. It has captured the interest of many people in search of a weight loss solution. And, there is no shortage of reported success stories. 

Despite the recent hype, the ketogenic diet is not new and was originally used in the 1960s in children who suffered from epilepsy. There is good evidence showing that a ketogenic diet reduces seizures in children, in some cases as effectively as medication.

This, however, needs to be done under medical supervision with the support of dietitians. Because of neuroprotective effects, questions have been raised about the possible benefits for other brain disorders, such as Parkinson’s disease, Alzheimer’s disease, multiple sclerosis, sleep disorders and autism.

To date, there are no human studies that support using ketosis to treat these conditions.

What exactly is the ketogenic diet?

The diet calls for the consumption of large amounts of fat, a moderate amount of protein and a very small amount of carbohydrates (< than 50 g/ day). As a percentage of daily calories, the nutrient split amounts to fat at 75–80%, protein at 15–20% and carbohydrates at 5%. This differs from the nutrient split of a nutritionally balanced calorie-restricted diet, which is 40–45% carbohydrates, 20% protein and 30–35% fat. 

When following the keto diet for about five days, due to the unavailability of carbohydrates, the body enters a state of ketosis, which means that it uses fat stores (instead of glucose) as a source of energy. There are several ketogenic supplements on the market that may contribute to reaching ketosis faster.

Keto-friendly foods include:

oils (e.g. olive oil, avocado oil, coconut oil); avocado; cream; butter; cream cheese; cheese; coconut; nuts; seeds; leafy green vegetables (e.g. spinach, kale, collards, romaine lettuce); non-starchy vegetables (e.g. zucchini, asparagus, cucumber, broccoli, cauliflower, bell peppers); meat (chicken, beef, pork, lamb); fish; eggs.

Non-keto-friendly foods include:

all processed foods; all sugar and sugar-containing foods, such as chocolates, sweets, pastries, sugary drinks; alcohol; milk; whole grains; all cereals; bread; rice; pasta; legumes (beans, peas, lentils); starchy vegetables (potato, sweet potato); and all fruit (except small portions of berries).

The ketogenic diet and weight loss

There is evidence of faster weight loss when following a ketogenic or exceptionally low carbohydrate diet, compared to a nutritionally balanced or Mediterranean diet. It is suggested that this is because of an increased feeling of fullness from eating a large amount of fat and protein. It is important to note that the observed differences in weight loss seem to disappear after two to three weeks. 

Research has found that in the long term (two to three months), the amount of weight lost by people following a ketogenic diet, was no more or less than the weight lost by people who followed a nutritionally balanced, energy-controlled diet. Evidence shows that there is no metabolic advantage when following this diet, but rather that weight loss results from an energy deficit, as is the case with all types of energy-controlled diets. You, therefore, do not have to push your body into a state of ketosis to achieve weight loss.

keto diet

The ketogenic diet and health risk

The ketogenic diet is not an easy diet to follow in the long term. In addition, there is evidence of an inadequate intake of some essential nutrients, as well as some health consequences when reducing carbohydrate intake too much and consuming excessive quantities of saturated fats. 

It is common for people starting the ketogenic diet to experience flu-like symptoms, such as headaches and fatigue. Also known as “keto flu”, characterised by bad breath, frequent urination and a dry mouth. Other potential risks include kidney stones, liver problems and vitamin and mineral deficiencies, especially calcium, selenium, and zinc.

Decreased bone mineral density and gastrointestinal distress, such as bloating and constipation due to the lack of fibre in the diet, have also been reported. 

The high intake of saturated fat found in fatty cuts of red meat, chicken skin, cheese, butter, and cream, contributes to an increase of LDL (the “bad” cholesterol) that increases the risk of heart disease. Excessive intake of saturated fat can also contribute to inflammation in the gastrointestinal tract.  

People who should avoid the ketogenic diet

  • Those who have a history of eating disorders can trigger a relapse when following a strict diet that eliminates food groups. 
  • Someone who has had a gallbladder removal should also avoid a keto diet. A gallbladder stores bile, which aids in fat digestion. Without this organ, you will not feel your best on a high-fat diet.
  • The long-term safety of the keto diet for people who have multiple sclerosis is questionable and they should be cautious of side effects, such as fatigue and constipation.
  • People who have kidney and liver problems as well as people who have heart disease, high blood pressure and type 2 diabetes should avoid a keto diet.
  • Pregnant and breast-feeding women should also be cautious.

The question of carbs

The objective of all popular weight-reducing diets is to restrict energy (calories). Research has shown that the extreme manipulation of a food group, whether fat, protein or carbohydrate, is a poor tool to teach any individual healthy eating habits that are essential to keep the weight off. 

The good side of the ketogenic diet is the elimination of unhealthy sugars and refined (white flour) carbohydrates. Research, however, has firmly established that replacing them with excessive quantities of protein of animal origin and saturated fats is not the answer.

Replacing unhealthy carbohydrates with controlled quantities of whole grains, legumes, fish, and a variety of fresh vegetables and fruit (in controlled portions) with nuts, seeds and vegetable oils, has shown significant health benefits towards weight loss, the avoidance of chronic lifestyle diseases and longevity.

These foods provide the necessary fibre, which is essential for optimal gut health, immunity and a reduced risk of colon cancer. In addition, the phytonutrients, vitamins, minerals, plant protein and essential fatty acids have been proven to reduce metabolic processes, such as inflammation and oxidative stress.

To conclude

Although a ketogenic diet may initially cause an encouraging amount of weight loss, it will be better to consult a dietitian to assist you in formulating a nutritionally balanced diet, taking your lifestyle, food preferences, culture, and budget in consideration. More importantly, a dietitian can help you find strategies to change the eating and lifestyle habits that caused your weight gain in the first place and replace them with habits that can keep the weight off in a sustained manner.

READ | What is the difference between low-carb and Keto?

READ| Constipation on the keto diet? Here’s what you should do

WATCH | The many benefits of a low-carb diet

Image credit: Jenna Hamra from Pexels

NEXT ON HEALTH24X

Share Button

Coronavirus: NHS waiting list ‘could hit 10 million this year’

Health leaders warn the coronavirus crisis will impact the number of people waiting for treatment.

Share Button