Obsession Director Admits He’s Spotted A Major ‘Plot Hole’ In The Hit Film

The hit film has broken box office records, and got the whole world talking about Bear, Nikki and the mysterious One Wish Willow.

Obsession follows Bear, who comes across a One Wish Willow that is supposed to grant his heart’s desire. However, when he wishes for his crush, Nikki, to fall deeply in love with him, things don’t quite work out as he intended, with deadly consequences for himself and those close to him.

If you’ve been picking apart the film and its meaning over the last few weeks, you may have spotted one part of it that doesn’t quite make sense – and so, apparently, has its director, Curry Barker.

During an interview with Total Film, it was pointed out that other One Wish Willow users had been complaining about how things had turned out for them, with the YouTuber-turned-director then being asked what he thought other people had been wishing for.

“I mean, it’s kind of a plot hole,” he admitted. “It’s something I don’t like to think about too much, because it totally doesn’t make sense that there’s a world of people just making wishes.”

Obsession director Curry Barker has admitted he's spotted a "plot hole" in his hit film
Obsession director Curry Barker has admitted he’s spotted a “plot hole” in his hit film

He added: “It really doesn’t make any sense at all. If the One Wish Willow actually works – which it does in this lore – and people are just making wishes left and right, there would be some crazy [things going on]. Like, dragons would exist.”

As Curry put it, the world in Obsession seems too “normal” for everyone to have access to these wish-granting sticks.

The writer-director went on to try and put forward a theory to explain this plot discrepancy, claiming: “Here’s my take – every time someone makes a wish, they enter into an alternate reality where their wish comes true, so you’re not experiencing everybody’s wish at the same time.”

However, he quickly realised that this theory presented its own issue, brought about when Ian’s billion-dollar wish comes true towards the end of the movie.

“That doesn’t make sense because the money falls from the ceiling,” he joked. “Yeah, it’s broken.”

Meanwhile, Curry has revealed to CinemaBlend that he is brainstorming ways of returning to the Obsession universe and expanding the One Wish Willow lore even further.

“I obviously have a couple more things that I’m excited about next, but I do see Obsession 2, maybe. Or even what really is exciting to me is maybe an anthology, like a one-hour episode,” he said, although we probably shouldn’t expect Nikki to return after that gruesome ending.

“Each episode is a different wish that goes completely off the rails. Maybe I’ll direct the pilot with the same DP, and you could invite other filmmakers to kind of give their spin at it. That would be really cool.”

Obsession is currently in cinemas.

Share Button

How A Classic Simpsons Episode Inspired One Of 2026’s Most Popular New Horrors

It turns out that filmmaker Curry Barker found inspiration from an unlikely source when he was putting together his hit horror movie Obsession.

A huge critical and commercial success, Obsession centres around two close friends whose lives are forever changed after one makes a wish for the other to love him “more than anyone else in the fucking world”.

When his wish comes true, things take a disastrous, and tragic, turn – with Curry getting the idea for his film from an iconic episode of The Simpsons.

Speaking to Triple J before Obsession’s release, the director explained that he had invited some friends over to watch an episode of the comedy It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia, which he made a guest appearance in.

“Before the episode [aired] there was a Simpsons episode where [Bart] has a monkey paw, and he’s making wishes and stuff,” he recalled.

Of course, Simpsons fans will know already that he’s referring to the show’s second ever Halloween special, Treehouse Of Horror II, which includes a segment where the family travels to Morocco and buys a cursed monkey’s paw at a market, which grants their wishes with sinister consequences.

The Simpsons' brush with a monkey's paw was an unexpected inspiration for Obsession
The Simpsons’ brush with a monkey’s paw was an unexpected inspiration for Obsession

He continued: “I was just excited to see my Always Sunny episode, but it hit me right then and there on the couch that Obsession idea that I had would be perfect if it was a wish movie.

“And so I actually remember the moment, I remember being on the couch, and being like, ‘oh my god’ and writing. It down. And after that, I just kept developing and developing that idea.”

In a separate interview with Variety, he said that after watching the Treehouse Of Horror special, he got to “thinking that I’ve never seen a straight crazy horror” based on that concept.

“We’ve seen ‘be careful what you wish for’ tons of times,” he noted. “But we’ve never seen my version of it. I instantly started thinking about what I could do with that…”

For what it’s worth, the Simpsons episode in question is based on WW Jacobs’ short story The Monkey’s Paw.

After coming up with his concept, Curry had to come up with a way of conveying the wish on screen, ruling out using a monkey’s paw because, as he told IndieWire, the image was already “too recognisable”.

He then considered going with a “wishing well”, “shooting stars” and “a wishbone”, before deciding on creating his own device, the One Wish Willow.

Since its release last month, Obsession has become one of the year’s most popular new films, with an enviable critical score of 96% on Rotten Tomatoes and 4.2 stars from fans on Letterboxd.

Obsession is in cinemas now.

Share Button